Your memory is correct. Here’s how the four second-year coaches rank through games played November 25, 2022. I’m tracking their overall record and record vs. Power 6 opponents.
1. TJ Otzelberger (Iowa State)
Overall: 27-13, 67.5%
Power 6: 16-13, 55.2%
2. Micah Shrewsberry (Penn State)
Overall: 20-18, 52.6%
Power 6: 11-17, 39.3%
3. Ben Johnson (Minnesota)
Overall: 17-19, 47.2%
Power 6: 6-18, 25%
4. Craig Smith (Utah)
Overall: 15-22, 40.5%
Power 6: 6-20, 23.1%
I’ll plan on updating this on GH every so often during the season.
Good work.
Wins and losses are the ultimate stat, period. This thread has a lot of talk about the talents of individuals, but wins and losses are team stats. Underneath the Ws and Ls are team offensive and defensive efficiency stats. You have to be good to great at least one end of the court to win games - it's not debatable.
So, I looked at these 4 teams on t-rank for 2020-21 (the year of the previous coach), 2021-22, and so far this year. Usual caveats about it being too early this year to be confident in the stats. Offensive rank is the first number and defensive is the second - think of every 35 teams as 10 percentiles (i.e., 35th is better than 90% of teams)
Iowa State:
2021 - 199, 141
2022 - 184, 5
2023 - 83, 13
Utah:
2021 - 27, 86
2022 - 92, 178
2023 - 140, 64
Penn St.:
2021 - 37, 62 (8th & 12th in the B1G)
2022 - 144, 66 (14th & 6th in the B1G)
2023 - 52, 57 (9th & 9th in the B1G)
Minnesota:
2021 - 88, 60 (12th & 11th in the B1G)
2022 - 98, 142 (12th & 13th in the B1G)
2023 - 220, 144 (14th & 14th in the B1G)
Clearly, Otzelberger chose defense to be good at.
Utah is a mixed bag.
PSU wasn't terrible with Chambers, but suffered due to a depth of other good teams in the B1G - i.e., when 37th best in the country is 8th in your conference, that's a good conference. They appear to have upgraded their O this year so far.
Minnesota - what exactly are you trying to be good at?