I didn't see the report, and I know you are paraphrasing not quoting, but I bristle at the use of the phrase "counter offers." It suggests that Coyle offered the position to both of them, which is almost certainly incorrect. It is possible that he made an offer to Musselman and a conditional offer to Dutcher ("we'd like to offer you $X over Y years, but only if Musselman turns us down") but that is rarely how negotiations work with high profile people. Far more likely, in my opinion, is that Coyle has reached out to representatives of the top candidates with a suggestion of what terms he'd propose if there is mutual interest and is awaiting responses. Then he can conduct interviews in whatever order he feels appropriate, but only with parties where there is a likley fit on the financial terms.