So many issues with the Vikings. The Kirk Cousins extension was an abomination the minute it was signed. There was simply zero reason to commit to Kirk in that manner. To make matters worse, the cap room they created by signing Kirk was not really used (they ended up keeping Harris on a Franchise tag) and they traded Diggs almost immediately after. Essentially, the Vikings were only half-way in on this season while committing to Cousins full stop. This was Spielman's biggest failure as GM. Beyond Cousins, he's shown an inability to identify offensive line talent, kickers and punters, and has really struggled to find talent after the 3rd round after the Diggs draft bonanza class. He somehow overpaid for Cook as well who has never played a full season yet signed a contract on par (or better than) Derrick Henry signed earlier this year.
As for Zimmer, his defense has always been better in his mind and in cumulative stats than in reality. Last year every starter on the defense with the exception of the 3 technique and the Free Safety was either highly paid for their position or a first or second round draft pick and many fell in to both those categories. This year was an opporunity for Zimmer to show his coaching chops with significantly less talent to work with. Zimmer then has taken to demand his team "run the ball" (even bizarrely mentioned it postgame today) so they can rely on his defense. When was the last time his defense truly shut down a good offense over 60 minutes. Lost in the debacle of last Sunday was Zimmer's defense allowing Seattle to go 94 yards in like 1:30 without ever having to use their one timeout to stop the clock. The reality is you better be Belichick on defense and occassionally put together a masterpiece if you are going to demand your offense be conservative (and Belichick doesn't demand that). The amount of 2nd and long runs this team calls is obscene and it's especially a ridiculous style for a team that knows it will play a minimum of 9 games a year in perfect indoor conditions.
Back to Cousins. If you are ready to move on, do you trust Spielman to make that quarterback choice? I certainly do not. If you are comfortable with that, how would you feel about Zimmer being his head coach? Look how he talked about Case in the media or how he ran the rookie kicker out of town. If both those things don't frighten you, it also doesn't make a lot of sense to take a big time QB prospect who has likely been playing primarily in the shotgun/pistol and put him in to this offense where the QB is often under center. None of those scenarios are ideal for a drafted QB to succeed and even in the best scenario it's always been a crapshoot in trying to find "the guy".
I agree with a lot of this.
I thought the main point of the Cousins extension was to move money out of this year's cap into a later year, or something like that. But seems like the money was mostly spent on Cook.
Cook might be a game changer. He is definitely great ... when he is healthy. Maybe he wasn't healthy the first two weeks, but I swear they kept giving it to Mattison on the 3rd down.
We played with
three rookie CBs yesterday, for a good part of the game. Yeah, don't forget we
also drafted Harrison Hand in 2020 (from Temple).
Hughes has to be a bust at this point. He can't stay healthy. Not sure what happened to Holton Hill, maybe he's hurt. Kris Boyd unfortunately hurt this week too (2019 draft pick from Texas).
Given our base seems to be a 4-2-5 now (I know they signed that vet #40, and he comes in occasionally for situations), and Eric Wilson really seems to be having a nice year. So he and Kendricks are good. Our safeties are great, if they never come off the field. Iloka nearly lost us the game vs the Texans.
I like the young DT they drafted this year (white kid out of Baylor). He seems hungry. Was unfortunate Stephan had to come off with an injury, hope he is ok.
Our DEs seem to be ok, but would be nice to get Hunter back.
I don't know. I've been trying to figure out what makes this team so much worse than 2019. I guess all the pieces missing on defense are just too much. Did Diggs really make that much of a difference on offense? Seems like Jefferson is a star, and Theilen and the rest are there. Maybe Cook really does matter that much.