Was this an offsides on us?

Did the refs get the call right?

  • Horrible call, we got fucked

    Votes: 111 94.9%

  • They made the right call

    Votes: 6 5.1%
  • Total voters
    117
Donate To GopherHole




Sparlimb said:
No it likely wasn't. But that wasn't why we lost. We lost because we gave a team that couldn't drive 80 yards and gave them two super short touchdowns.
Click to expand...

Games are 60 minutes long. Stuff happens at the beginning of the game and at the end. The Gophers should have had a shot to win.....or at the very least......tie the game regardless of what happened in the first half.
 


It’s a call you have to be ABSOLUTELY POSITIVE to make at any point in the game. 100% a blown call and it erased any chance. Wasn’t the only reason we lost, but was the final straw that took away the last good chance
 







I don't get the mindset of we didn't lose because of one play it was because of the other one play. All of the mistakes aside the Gophers were in position to tie or win the game. You can't make that call. Also a play like that not being reviewable, why? What is the point of replay then?
 

GopherGuy82 said:
I don't get the mindset of we didn't lose because of one play it was because of the other one play. All of the mistakes aside the Gophers were in position to tie or win the game. You can't make that call. Also a play like that not being reviewable, why? What is the point of replay then?
Click to expand...
Not reviewable because if they did it for one penalty, you gotta do it for them all then you’re reviewing holding all year
 







Are we sure hands/arm isn’t across. I realize it isn’t called consistently but my understanding is any part of body qualifies.
 



Someone on twitter pointed it out that the ball hit number 0 in the knees just before the 45 yard line.

 

gophersfan said:
Someone on twitter pointed it out that the ball hit number 0 in the knees just before the 45 yard line.

Click to expand...

It's close. But if that were the case.....illegal touching CAN be reviewed. You can't review an offsides call.
 




upnorthkid said:
Well there’s a bunch of Michigan fans saying it was a horrible call so that says all you need to know
Click to expand...

I have no doubt many there are hating on their staff for what was an ugly win ugly second half, fortunate escape. Nobody’s happy with the game but they get a W in the win column, at least. They can see MN was close to the upset.
 




upnorthkid said:
Not reviewable because if they did it for one penalty, you gotta do it for them all then you’re reviewing holding all year
Click to expand...
Wrong. There are other penalties relating to being across a line that are already reviewable (see below). No reason offside on an onside kick couldn’t be added to the list of reviewable fouls.

2024 NCAA Rulebook
Rule 12 Instant Replay

Reviewable Fouls ​

ARTICLE 8. The following plays are reviewable and the replay official may create a foul when there is no call by the on-field officials:​

a. Player making a forward pass or forward handoff when the player’s entire body and the ball is or has been beyond the neutral zone or after a change of possession (Rule 12-3-2c and 12-3-2d).​

b. Player kicking the ball when the player's entire body and the ball is or has been beyond the neutral zone.​


c. Blocking by players of the kicking team before they are eligible to touch the ball on an onside kick (Rule 12-3-4e).​

 


You must log in or register to reply here.



Top Bottom