Exactly what in Royce White's past leads you to take his word about what Tubby/Maturi/anyone did or did not communicate to him?
I have my share of concerns with Tubby, but I certainly wouldn't side with a wildcard like Royce White in an integrity contest with Orlando Smith.
If, in fact, it was communicated to Royce that he would not play for the Gophers this year, despite any resolution with his charges, this information should have been shared to the public. The fact that it wasn't led to a lot of frustrated Gophers fans.
If Royce were to lie and say that he expected to play or make leading statements to this effect after being told that he wouldn't play (I'm not sure if he ever did this or if it was all just rumors), he should have been dismissed from the team. That sort of conduct would be clearly detrimental to the program.
Either way, I believe the process was clearly handled poorly by all involved.