Depends on the scenario (good example in this case is that they have 3 WR recruits committed we have none/early playing time etc.).
Just to preface, I went to school of a year at UW prior to transferring to the U. Apart from where the programs are at Wisconsin should have ZERO advantage with out state recruits on the U. The reason I left was because there was literally nothing to do besides party. MPLS has so much to offer! From all of the professional sporting events, concerts, outdoor life, MOA, restaurants, Valley Fair etc. to the different lifestyles i.e uptown, downtown. dinkytown etc.
There is literally no difference in the weather and the education you receive at either school is wonderful. However, going to the U opens up a ton of doors because of all the fortune 1000 companies that are headquartered here. So IMO, the only advantages that they have are on the field success (recent) and fan following (recent). I don't want any Badger fans saying that they were packing Camp Randall when they were terrible, cus that just wasn't happening!