What exactly do you know about "Reading progressions" anyhow, other than what you learned playing "Madden"?
I never said I could do it, but I sure as hell know plenty about it. I can't dunk a basketball, but I know what it is. I can't hit a 95-mph fastball, but I know what it is. I can't perform open-heart surgery, but I know what it is. I know that a concept like "Look for the 7, if it's not there, look for the 2, if it's not there, check down to your back" is pretty hard to comprehend, but somehow, through watching, playing, following, reading about, and writing about football for 25 years I've managed to grasp it.
I'm not sure whether or not Weber understands the concept, but he sure as hell can't execute it. I don't know what games you've been watching, but I've seen every snap Weber took, whether live, on television, or on DVR, and a play wherein he threw somewhere other than his first option was extremely rare. And yet, despite his proclivity to lock on and throw to his first target, regardless of the coverage, he still somehow managed to take an inordinate number of sacks by holding onto the ball too long. One would assume those two are mutually exclusive, but then again, Weber did set a new standard for bizarre and losing QB play. All of this is not even mentioning his poor accuracy both long and short, as well as outside the hashmarks. If you drew a box from hash to hash, and from 7- to 15-yards downfield, that's the only area where Weber is actually an above-average QB. If there exists an OC whose passing tree consists solely of 3s, 5s, and 7s, Weber could be a Pro Bowler, but something tells me that an NFL DC might catch on to that pretty quickly.
Like someone already said, I'm sure Weber looks like Joe Montana in one-on-ones and skeleton drills, but if you really want to see what he's all about, the only evaluation worth watching is a scrimmage versus a live rush. There you'll see his deer-in-the-headlights, spin-move-right-into-a-DE's-arms, bounce-pass-on-a-3-yard-out-route routine, and I don't know how you as a talent evaluator won't be itching to offer him a multi-million-dollar signing bonus as soon as possible.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1c4fb/1c4fb4a004ac374ae735c210f8560be0dce354ac" alt="Roll eyes :rolleyes: :rolleyes:"