2024 MN High School Football thread

Donate To GopherHole
MaxyJR1 said:
Maple Grove 42-12 over Edina in a running time game.

Minnetonka 28-0 over Blaine. Blaine QB broke collarbone while driving Blaine to potentially tie the game at 7.
Click to expand...
I've heard of quite a few QBs breaking collar bones this year. I'm far removed from moderm FB equipment. Are QBs wearing specialized shoulder pads or something?
 

swede2 said:
I've heard of quite a few QBs breaking collar bones this year. I'm far removed from moderm FB equipment. Are QBs wearing specialized shoulder pads or something?
Click to expand...
With more and more cows being machine milked instead of hand milked, the milk has less calcium in it. Makes for brittle bones.
 

MaxyJR1 said:
2A.

Staples Motley over Barnesville 46-42
Hatfield 23-22 over Triton
Click to expand...

shouldn't the Hatfields be playing the McCoys?

I apologize. couldn't resist. I've probably made more typos than anyone in my career - but most of my copy was written for radio, so no one knew. when I would write up traffic accidents, I had a bad habit of writing that a car had a broken Windom (instead of window). If someone else was reading the copy, they were usually get mad at me if they read it cold without pre-reading it first....
 

short ornery norwegian said:
shouldn't the Hatfields be playing the McCoys?

I apologize. couldn't resist. I've probably made more typos than anyone in my career - but most of my copy was written for radio, so no one knew. when I would write up traffic accidents, I had a bad habit of writing that a car had a broken Windom (instead of window). If someone else was reading the copy, they were usually get mad at me if they read it cold without pre-reading it first....
Click to expand...
Just trying to beat you to the punch and failed miserably.
 

13 games last night and only 3 were under a 3 score difference.

Springfield scored on a long pass with under 30 seconds to beat Goodhue 20-14.
Chatfield scored with 1 minute to play and made the ExP to win 23-22
Staples-Motley over Barnesville in 2OT. 46-44. Crazy that both teams went for 2 on every score.
 


swede2 said:
I've heard of quite a few QBs breaking collar bones this year. I'm far removed from moderm FB equipment. Are QBs wearing specialized shoulder pads or something?
Click to expand...
Qbs have worn different style pads for a long time. But all the shoulder pads now are minuscule in size compared to just a few year back. Go look at highlights of Randy Moss, his shoulder pads would be the largest worn in an NFL game today.

They are still protective with the materials they are made from but I don't exactly think they are as protective as years gone by. Free movement and comfort are much preferred by a player than bulky protective gear.
 

MaxyJR1 said:
13 games last night and only 3 were under a 3 score difference.

Springfield scored on a long pass with under 30 seconds to beat Goodhue 20-14.
Chatfield scored with 1 minute to play and made the ExP to win 23-22
Staples-Motley over Barnesville in 2OT. 46-44. Crazy that both teams went for 2 on every score.
Click to expand...
Staples best WR is a very good kicker and they also have 1 more kid that can kick extra points as well. Was strange to see them not try kick an extra point.
 

MaxyJR1 said:
Maple Grove 42-12 over Edina in a running time game.

Minnetonka 28-0 over Blaine. Blaine QB broke collarbone while driving Blaine to potentially tie the game at 7.
Click to expand...
Winners not surprising, scores were though.
 

MaxyJR1 said:
Maple Grove 42-12 over Edina in a running time game.

Minnetonka 28-0 over Blaine. Blaine QB broke collarbone while driving Blaine to potentially tie the game at 7.
Click to expand...
This is why people shouldn’t necessarily rig the playoff system so some sections are seeded higher than others.

The current system put the third place team from the west in the same bracket as the first place team from the north. I thought Edina was a top 3 team in the state possibly going into the playoffs…but they earned a 3 seed. They shouldn’t jump a 1-2 seed from another section just because I think the west is better.
 
Last edited:



WoodburyTim said:
With more and more cows being machine milked instead of hand milked, the milk has less calcium in it. Makes for brittle bones.
Click to expand...
Maybe or maybe with less and less real football at practice kids don’t know how to roll into it and avoid the force while being tackled.

Freshmen QBs used to play both ways and get hit in practice even 10 years ago.

We have specialization of kids at QB and all the time playing non contact.
Collarbone injuries are usually freak injuries but when they are avoidable it is because you can roll into a hit to disperse the force to your whole body.

There are varsity QBs who haven’t been hit in a practice since 8th grade at the 6a level.
 

Some guy said:
This is why people shouldn’t necessarily rig the playoff system so some sections are seeded higher than others.

The current system put the third place team from the west in the same bracket as the first place team from the west. I thought Edina was a top 3 team in the state possibly going into the playoffs…but they earned a 3 seed. They shouldn’t jump a 1-2 seed from another section just because I think the west is better.
Click to expand...
Are you saying Minnetonka and Shakopee were seeded wrong? Minnetonka was #1 from the West and opposite Edina and Shakopee.

or are you saying you like this system?
 

4A Semi Finals set with Cross Over Bracketing.

Marshall vs Becker at 10:30am Thursday at USBank
Orono vs Totino Grace at 11:30am on Friday TG beat Orono 11-8 back in week 7.
 

MaxyJR1 said:
4A Semi Finals set with Cross Over Bracketing.

Marshall vs Becker at 10:30am Thursday at USBank
Orono vs Totino Grace at 11:30am on Friday TG beat Orono 11-8 back in week 7.
Click to expand...
Looking forward to the Totino-Orono, don’t think the Becker Marshall game will be close unfortunately
 



dog mustard said:
Looking forward to the Totino-Orono, don’t think the Becker Marshall game will be close unfortunately
Click to expand...
Both Marshall and Becker blew out common opponents Willmar and Hutchinson. Becker looked to have a little easier time though.
 

MaxyJR1 said:
Are you saying Minnetonka and Shakopee were seeded wrong? Minnetonka was #1 from the West and opposite Edina and Shakopee.

or are you saying you like this system?
Click to expand...
I am not saying that. I am saying that some are saying that. But to rank Edina as a 2 over forest lake or anoka is purely subjective. So Edina being the 3 is fair. They beat the 2 from the south. They lost to the 1 and 2 from the west this year and the 1 from the north.

They made it to the round of 8.
They have 3 losses and lost in the round of 8. Maybe they’re the 4th best team this year, maybe they aren’t. But I think the current model is the fairest we can get for playoffs. There are greater tragedies in the world than the 4th best team losing in the round of 8 instead of the round of 4. Edina is somewhere between the 4th best and 7th best IMO
 

MaxyJR1 said:
Both Marshall and Becker blew out common opponents Willmar and Hutchinson. Becker looked to have a little easier time though.
Click to expand...
Looking again, their win against Byron looks impressive on paper. We’ll find out soon enough
 

Some guy said:
I am not saying that. I am saying that some are saying that. But to rank Edina as a 2 over forest lake or anoka is purely subjective. So Edina being the 3 is fair. They beat the 2 from the south. They lost to the 1 and 2 from the west this year and the 1 from the north.

They made it to the round of 8.
They have 3 losses and lost in the round of 8. Maybe they’re the 4th best team this year, maybe they aren’t. But I think the current model is the fairest we can get for playoffs. There are greater tragedies in the world than the 4th best team losing in the round of 8 instead of the round of 4. Edina is somewhere between the 4th best and 7th best IM
Click to expand...

I'd say it's #1Maple Grove and #2 The Field and I think Shakopee is the only team that could beat them as they run similar to what Centennial does. Centennial gives MG really good games.

In the end there is one Champion.

Here were the last Rankings.

1, 2, 4, 5, 9, and unranked Anoka remaining

I'd say the way that 6A brackets is pretty successful and gets the best teams to the Bank. If Anoka and MV lose, you have 1, 2, 4, 5 at the Bank. Edina was ranked 3 but had a loss to a team behind them in Tonka. Tonka only had the extra loss because they drew MG in their cross over game. The rankings were more wrong than the seeding. Same with Forest Lake and Mounds View being ranked wrong in the final poll.

I think Anoka, Mounds View and Blaine are really good teams. We'll see what tonight says for two of them. I think the Tonka/Blaine game is completely different if the Blaine QB doesn't get hurt.



1.Maple Grove8-0-0
2.Shakopee7-1-0
3.Edina6-2-0
4.Lakeville North7-1-0
5.Minnetonka6-2-0
6.Eden Prairie5-3-0
7.Forest Lake6-2-0
8.Eagan5-3-0
9.Mounds View6-2-0
10.Blaine5-3-0
 


Jackson County Central - 1st offensive play of the game - Roman Voss with a 73-yard run for a TD.
 




After blowouts last night.....6A getting a couple tight ones tonight. Looks like Shakopee and North both up 3 in the 4th quarter of their games.
 

MNVCGUY said:
After blowouts last night.....6A getting a couple tight ones tonight. Looks like Shakopee and North both up 3 in the 4th quarter of their games.
Click to expand...
Anoka 14-10
Shakopee 24-17

2 1’s and 2 2’s in the final 4.
 


MNVCGUY said:
Feels like a Maple Grove/Minnetonka rematch coming in the finals but Shakopee will most likely give Maple Grove a battle.
Click to expand...
Hard to argue. Anoka defense was really good tonight.
 

MNVCGUY said:
Feels like a Maple Grove/Minnetonka rematch coming in the finals but Shakopee will most likely give Maple Grove a battle.
Click to expand...
I think shakopee is the biggest challenger


I picked shakopee to win it. But then picked against them tonight.
They got a 17-0 lead and held on 24-17
 

Some guy said:
I think shakopee is the biggest challenger


I picked shakopee to win it. But then picked against them tonight.
They got a 17-0 lead and held on 24-17
Click to expand...
Should be interesting. Haven't see Maple Grove in person but was extremely impressed by Shakopee when I saw them.

Hopefully they can give Maple Grove a battle.
 

MNVCGUY said:
Should be interesting. Haven't see Maple Grove in person but was extremely impressed by Shakopee when I saw them.

Hopefully they can give Maple Grove a battle.
Click to expand...
I have not seen maple grove live

Hard to know how good they were because the north never crossed over with other three sections until week 8

They clearly are the favorite after their week 8 game.
I personally would pick Edina and shakopee over Minnetonka.
MG already crushed Edina. So I feel it’s shakopee or MG for the title
 

MN HS FB State Tournament Scoreboard - Quarter-Final Round - Friday, Nov 8

9-pl: (S1) LeRoy-Ostrander/Lyle/Pacelli 50, (S4) Renville County West 0

1A: (S1) Minneota 41, (S4) Lester Prairie 0
---(N2) Mahnomen-Waubun 14, (N3) Deer River 6

2A: (N1) Kimball Area 38, (N4) Moose Lake-Willow River 0
--- (S2) Jackson County Central 34, (S3) Norwood-Young America 7

3A: (N4) Albany 28, (N1) Fergus Falls 27

6A: Anoka 14, Lakeville North 10
--- Shakopee 24, Mounds View 17

(as noted, JCC QB Roman Voss left his game after an apparent ankle injury and was on crutches on the sideline. haven't seen anything yet on his outlook, but hard to believe he'll be OK in a week. JCC will play Kimball Area in the Semis at 9am next Friday.)

------------- --------------------------
Games on Saturday:

3A: (N2) Pequot Lakes vs (N3) Annandale - 7pm @ Rocori HS
--- (S1) Stewartville vs (S4) Holy Family Catholic - Noon at Totino-Grace HS
--- (S2 Dassel-Cokato vs (S3) Fairmont - 3pm @ Mpls Washburn HS

5A: (N1) Elk River vs (N4) Monticello - 4pm @ Forest Lake HS
--- (N2) Robbinsdale Armstrong vs (N3) Alexandria - 11am @ Monticello HS
--- (S1) Owatonna vs (S4) Cretin-Derham Hall - 1pm @ Eastview HS
--- (S2) Chanhassen vs (S3) St. Thomas Academy - Noon @ Osseo HS
 

You must log in or register to reply here.



Top Bottom