I completely understand what you're saying, but I guess I never thought that we were going to find replacements for Mbakwe and Rodney with this recruiting cycle. That's what makes college basketball interesting, players leave and you just can't replace them with free agents. The younger guys need to step up.
Replacing Mbakwe is going to be impossible. I don't think we would have found a replacement with Alex Foster and I don't think we'll be able to just find replacements in recruiting. He was a special player. You can't really blame a coach for a guy of Mbakwe's caliber graduating.
Yeah, losing Joe Coleman hurts because he was a decent player. But I've noticed that some people on here are upset about losing a decent player (borderline starter/bench player) and then upset when we replace that player with another guy who is simply decent. I don't think there is much of a difference in terms of ability between Malik Smith and Joe Coleman. So while I think Joe could play and help us, I don't think it will be statistically much more than Malik Smith will help us. I could be wrong.
Julian Welch? I try not to bash Gopher players, but if Dre Mathieu doesn't do more than Welch, we are in some trouble. He was terrible last year. If Dre Mathieu plays OK basketball (decent Big 10 basketball player level) and takes a large portion of the minutes from Welch and Mav (from last year). . .that's a massive upgrade. Welch was a reserve, the fact that he was playing was a problem.
Andre Ingram? I'm not trying to bash Andre, but he put up under 2 points and under 2 rebounds per game. He had some nice moments and he provided decent depth, but I'd be shocked if we didn't get quite a bit more out of Joey King, heck for as bad as Oto has been, we got about as much out of him as we did Andre.
My main point is that we have been stuck giving minutes to a lot of guys who are not Big 10 caliber basketball players. Malik Smith is an obvious no-brainer, he isn't a gamble at all (he's gone after this year). The people who don't seem to like Joey King don't seem to like him because he won't be a complete basketball player. But if King is simply a big guy off the bench who can shoot and give us some QUALITY depth, I am all for the signing. I also thought we desperately needed a PG, so I can't blame a coach for bringing in a JuCo PG. So to sum up my incredibly long winded point. . .if Joey King, Dre Mathieu and Malik Smith are nothing more than QUALITY reserves. . .the signings make a ton of sense.