Schnauzer
Pretty Sure You are Wrong
- Joined
- Jun 4, 2009
- Messages
- 6,652
- Reaction score
- 3,595
- Points
- 113
some thoughts regarding the new playoff structure...
First, the background:
1. 12 teams, 4 with first round byes and 8 (4 first round winners and 4 that had first round byes) that play in the quarter final round.
2. first round is played at the home stadium of the higher seed. Seeds 5-12 around December 20 or so.
3. The quarterfinal games are played in rotating traditional New Year's 6 bowls with one on New Years Eve and the other three on New Years Day.
4. The semifinals are played at the remining two rotating New Year's six sites, around January 8-9. So all six of the biggest bowls host one playoff game (four quarter finals and two semi finals)
5. The two remaining finalists meet in the national championship game, hosted at a bid site around January 20.
In general, I like it and I like the dates and prospective sites selected to host each round. I do think it will be better than the four team playoff, which was becoming more of an elite invitational event with the same teams every year than it was a "playoff."
But, there are a few things that are wonky...
1. No bowls for the first round losers. For example, say Indiana gets into the playoff and has to travel (and loses) an away game in the opposition's stadium. Their once-in-a-lifetime season could end on a frigid evening in front of a hostile crowd. No bowl swag packs. No battles of the bands on a field under palm trees or on a beach. No opportunity for throngs of fans gobbling up tickets and hotel rooms to party a holiday weekend away ready to cheer their favorite team on.
2. Because of #1, the non playoff bowls will further degenerate into "exhibitions" instead of exciting bowls played between big programs that normally don't see each other in the regular season. These "other" bowls were already in decline. Players sitting out. Coaches moving on to other jobs prior to gameday. Etc. You really have to wonder if the shine will come off of the long lineup of lesser bowls in an accelerated way.
3. Bank-breakers for fan bases going deep into the playoffs. This one is pretty self-explanatory but as a fan how would you like to fork over vacation, money, plane tickets, hotels, etc. for, let's say, the Rose bowl on Jan 1, then the Sugar Bowl on Jan 9, and then the championship on Jan 20. Will some of these big time games be played in front of half-full stadiums?
The bowl culture is so strong, it is easy to see why it has taken this long to come up with a 12 team tourney.
First, the background:
1. 12 teams, 4 with first round byes and 8 (4 first round winners and 4 that had first round byes) that play in the quarter final round.
2. first round is played at the home stadium of the higher seed. Seeds 5-12 around December 20 or so.
3. The quarterfinal games are played in rotating traditional New Year's 6 bowls with one on New Years Eve and the other three on New Years Day.
4. The semifinals are played at the remining two rotating New Year's six sites, around January 8-9. So all six of the biggest bowls host one playoff game (four quarter finals and two semi finals)
5. The two remaining finalists meet in the national championship game, hosted at a bid site around January 20.
In general, I like it and I like the dates and prospective sites selected to host each round. I do think it will be better than the four team playoff, which was becoming more of an elite invitational event with the same teams every year than it was a "playoff."
But, there are a few things that are wonky...
1. No bowls for the first round losers. For example, say Indiana gets into the playoff and has to travel (and loses) an away game in the opposition's stadium. Their once-in-a-lifetime season could end on a frigid evening in front of a hostile crowd. No bowl swag packs. No battles of the bands on a field under palm trees or on a beach. No opportunity for throngs of fans gobbling up tickets and hotel rooms to party a holiday weekend away ready to cheer their favorite team on.
2. Because of #1, the non playoff bowls will further degenerate into "exhibitions" instead of exciting bowls played between big programs that normally don't see each other in the regular season. These "other" bowls were already in decline. Players sitting out. Coaches moving on to other jobs prior to gameday. Etc. You really have to wonder if the shine will come off of the long lineup of lesser bowls in an accelerated way.
3. Bank-breakers for fan bases going deep into the playoffs. This one is pretty self-explanatory but as a fan how would you like to fork over vacation, money, plane tickets, hotels, etc. for, let's say, the Rose bowl on Jan 1, then the Sugar Bowl on Jan 9, and then the championship on Jan 20. Will some of these big time games be played in front of half-full stadiums?
The bowl culture is so strong, it is easy to see why it has taken this long to come up with a 12 team tourney.