This is one step below professional ball, but it is not professional ball. The rules are different. If you offer a scholarship the player gets it for four years, if he is not as good as you had hoped, that is a failure by the coaches. The player still has every right to his four years. He cannot be cut due to not being as good as the coaches had hoped. Anything beyond open discussion about where the player falls on the depth chart is starting to go too far in my opinion. If a player wants to ride the bench for four years while getting free education then that is his right per the contract he signed. I am sure coaches have methods I don’t agree with to get kids to transfer out, which I personally think should be policed, but good luck with that. We’ve seen examples like Ben St Juste where Michigan pushed him to medically retire, obviously to get him off the roster, since he is now in the nfl.