Costa Rican Gopher
Mind of a Scientist
- Joined
- Nov 22, 2008
- Messages
- 28,570
- Reaction score
- 6,896
- Points
- 113
Could it be all those train stations were included because there are people who live, work, and do business in Minneapolis and St. Paul other than in the two central business districts? Get back to us after you have calculated and included in your analysis the amount of time and the total cost to drive and park your car in downtown Minneapolis or St. Paul or at the U. Your analysis should also include the projected vehicle travel times and parking fees for the next 25 years with minimal construction of freeways and downtown parking ramps. I believe a large percentage of the riders on the existing LRT between downtown Minneapolis and the Mega Mall wouldn't ever consider riding a bus anywhere or any time. I am one of them. Then do the necessary research and inform us of all the times that a major capital project in any city in America with a population of over 100,000 people didn't involve politics. Until then we have no choice but to conclude that you didn't fully think through your post. It goes without saying that Costa didn't think through his post.
Try to show some class & discuss the topic without personal attacks.
Point blank, each light rail project is different. Comparing the Hiawatha line which has critical mass due to MSP airport & the MOA to the North Star (3 trains a day total) or the unknown of the Green Line is apples to oranges at best.
I actually think the Green Line is a good idea. I think St Paul is underutilized & this will help connect the two cities again. University Ave should be a vital artery, not the run down, ghost town it had become & you can visibly see the difference on University Ave since the construction began. New businesses are popping up & the cheap foreclosures/condemned houses were gobbled up & renovated into decent rentals. In fact, rents in Frogtown went up 43% alone last year, much to the displeasure of the local community (mostly low income minorities), so it's changing quickly.
My problems with the Green Line are:
A) That it's way too slow. 40 Minutes is unreasonable when I can drive it in 15 minutes or take a bus in 26-28 minutes. Surely you can see why that will dissuade people from using it as their main source for commuting once the novelty wears off?
B) My other problem with it is how unsafe it is. Unlike the Hiawatha line that runs parallel to Hiawatha Ave, the Green Line runs right down the middle of University Ave so the street itself is much more narrow & difficult for cars to maneuver, which makes it more dangerous & will hurt businesses along the route. This design also disregards public safety. On normal train tracks there's a red flashing light & a gate goes down when a train's coming. There's a good reason for that, people are dumb! The Hiawatha line has a similar set up so people don't turn into or drive straight into the train. University Ave though has nothing of the sort as evidenced by the guy who drove right into the train a couple days ago. It's not even open yet & it's already become an issue.
Like I said, I'm in favor of the Green Line, just not the hair brained way it was designed. I'll use it to go to Gopher games, as will many others coming from the Eastern Suburbs, but realistically that's the only time it would make sense for me, as someone who lives in St Paul.