Sparlimb
Well-known member
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2008
- Messages
- 10,855
- Reaction score
- 1,210
- Points
- 113
I have it the Gophers are going back to the single wing. We are almost playing it already. No WRs just TEs and RBs.
We have WRs?!?
I have it the Gophers are going back to the single wing. We are almost playing it already. No WRs just TEs and RBs.
No thanks. I even specified that it has nothing to do with the kid himself. If he's an in-state player with offers from FAU and Air Force, it's questionable recruiting strategy to offer him in October. He's basically a Ben Lauer-level recruit, and the Gophers wisely held out on Lauer and offered him just before signing day. That doesn't mean Lingen can't and won't be an impact player, as evidenced by Lauer starting in his 2nd year. It just means that the recruiting strategy is very peculiar.
I don't care about Brandon Lingen outside of his potential ability to play for the Gophers. I'm sorry if that offends anyone. If he were just some random kid from Wayzata and not a Division I football prospect, he wouldn't be discussed here. I care about the Gophers, not about Brandon Lingen. Scholarships are like gold, especially for a program trying to dig out of the bottom quartile of the Big Ten. If they like him a lot, great, but I'm pretty sure an offer could've waited until January or February after other options were exhausted. Maybe they got wind of a forthcoming offer from Iowa or Wisconsin, but I doubt it.
Now, does anyone else feel the need to chirp away at an honest opinion because someone's feelings might get hurt?
I agree the offer seems somewhat odd, but is it possible that he's playing extremely well and is all of a sudden drawing a lot of interest from other schools? I honestly don't know much about Lingen so I could be way off. Just a thought.
Interesting that Rivals initial rank for him is 3 stars.
Interesting that Rivals initial rank for him is 3 stars.
Very few on here defend the importance of the star system as much as dpodoll68. Now that Lingren is a 3-star commit, I would hope he apologizes for his temper tantrum he threw on this thread.
Please dont poke the bear, I dont enjoy the pissing matches.
The staff has been holding onto scholarships in this class like they are gold. Out of 8 commits, 3 are big-time recruits that could go practically anywhere they wanted (Jones, Mayes, Elmore), two are midwestern kids with good offer lists (McKinzy, Stelter), and 2 were lightly recruited but the staff made them a high priority and offered last spring (Richardson, Williams). The Lingen offer/commitment means one of 3 things:
1. The staff liked him a lot at camp, was very impressed with his senior film, and decided they couldn't let the #7 ranked player in the state get away.
2. All of the above, but they see him at a different position (OL, DE).
3. Another development has taken place (potential transfer, etc.) that we don't know about yet.
The staff also closely watch George Behr and Zach Hovey, and decided that out of the 3 they wanted Lingen. Even though it's somewhat of a head-scratcher, I'll give them the benefit of the doubt since they have been very selective so far.
I totally agree with lakesgopher and DP on this one as well. Am I Dp's alter ego or lap dog too?
Very few on here defend the importance of the star system as much as dpodoll68. Now that Lingren is a 3-star commit, I would hope he apologizes for his temper tantrum he threw on this thread.
Can we all stop hyperventilating now?
Kill did say on his radio show today that they are having a great week recruiting.
Didn't mean to start the pissing match but after watching the video someone posted, I would guess he will be a tackle before long.
Welcome aboard!
I agree that it is questionable to offer someone who has already committed elsewhere. Probably why it doesn't happen often.
If you blindly agreed with dp about 1,000 more times, but I don't see you as a lap dog, maybe more like a dingleberry.
I know I'm beating an old dead horse but gotta love the Minnesota recruits; wouldn't Billy Turner (LT), Grant Olson and AJ Tarpley (LB) and Zach Vraa fill some gaping holes on our squad. Ugh, makes me a bit queasy just thinking about it. I think that is probably Brewster's biggest kick in the nuts; out recruiting the hinterlands for morons like Jew Jew Edwards and for kids who can't play (see his last two recruiting classes) while we let more than a handful of really good players get away. Anyway, bring the kid on board whether he's a TE/DE/OT he looks like he has some skills.
you'll second guess Kill's recruits before ever seeing them play, but won't second guess Brewster's failures?Hindsight is fun isn't it? Maybe u can rehash these thoughts for the next crop of Minnesota kids that go to the Dakotas and have success.
Hindsight is fun isn't it? Maybe u can rehash these thoughts for the next crop of Minnesota kids that go to the Dakotas and have success.
you'll second guess Kill's recruits before ever seeing them play, but won't second guess Brewster's failures?
That's the thing, though. It's not really hindsight these kids ripped it up during their HS careers and were deserving an offer of their hometown team. I believe that while Brewster that year was focused on renting a helicopter to try and impress Seantreall, had Kill been here then he would have offered and gotten these kids; perhaps Tarpley notwithstanding with his Stanford offer. There were a good crop of Minnesota players around that year and Brew wasn't paying attention. These kids aren't having just having success they're dominant players and would be difference makers here. If I put Zenner on this list then it would be hindsight. I don't think anyone really saw his absurd level of success coming but the four mentioned have "it" and i saw them all play in person and it was hard to miss; unless again you were up in the clouds in your helicopter or flying to the hinterlands to recruit marginal players with marginal character as our boy Brew was.
you'll second guess Kill's recruits before ever seeing them play, but won't second guess Brewster's failures?
He was injured his junior year.His film is pretty impressive. Rivals just graded him out at 3 stars. Hope that enlightens you.Pretty strange offer this early in the recruiting cycle and in what will be a small class. He might turn out to be the next Ben Utecht, but the strategy is totally messed up. Color me unimpressed.