WF fan here, guys. I have no idea if we'll make a run at Tubby (I hope we do), but came over here to see if there were any threads about it and saw the Gaudio thread.
You have to realize that Dino's tenure is viewed kind of as an extension of Skip's. Skip, god rest his soul, did not have a good last few years at Wake, but there was optimism on the horizon with a top recruiting class coming in at the time of his death. Dino was the logical and players' choice to keep the ship afloat, even though his own head coaching resume at that point was lackluster to say the least.
Dino has continued to recruit well, but he is not much of a gameday coach at all. You can look at the records all you want, but can't ignore other things, such as the late-season flameouts (losing to bad teams badly in the reg season this year, being completely uncompetitive in the ACC tourney the last three years, and getting destroyed early and often in the NCAAs to Cleveland St. and Kentucky. The win over Texas counts for very little, since Texas was the one team in the tourney playing as poorly as Wake going into the Big Dance), and general poor coaching. There are also consistent issues with a lack of fundamental hoops IQ on the court and how they remained uncorrected over both Dino's and Skip's tenure. One thing I'll say for Dino is he made his teams defensive-minded, and that was to his benefit initially-- particularly during his first season. But his teams had no offense unless they were running in transition. The half-court sets consisted of dribbling around a lot and finding somebody to toss the ball in the general vicinity of the basket.
In the end, most fans felt Dino was a good guy and needed to be the guy after Skip left us, but that his 3 year trial had not met expectations and we needed a change. If they are surprised, it's that it took this long after the UK loss to fire him.
I don't know where Pewterschmidt got the negative recruiting thing, but I'm not going to rail on another poster with my first post, particularly one with over 3000 posts on his team's message board. All I know is that is the first time I've ever heard that accusation levied against Gaudio. As for the Herb Brooks comparison, I don't know if that's good or bad. At least Herb's teams did something when it counted.
Back to Tubby... With Stevens now out of the question (I never held out a reasonable hope for him anyway), most Wake fans seem warm to the idea of Tubby. It is the southeast (a better place to retire than the upper midwest), and he has ties to the area. From our perspective, he would lend instant credibility to the program. Wake fans don't expect to beat Duke and UNC on a regular basis, but we would like to beat them about half the time and have some postseason success, which is something we have not experienced in a while. #1 rankings don't mean much if you can't hold them for more than a week and die early and often in the tourney every year. If that's pressure, I think that is the kind of pressure a lot of people can stand, to include an aging Tubby Smith. Do I think we'll get him? Well, I don't even know who we're making a run at. Our AD, Ron Wellman, seems to be keeping things well under wraps. I suspect, however, that if he was making a run at Tubby that somebody in Minnesota's vast network of boosters would know about it and leak it. It is hard to keep a secret these days, especially with a high profile name like Tubby's.