It is unreal how SS seems to get inside the head of the selection committee. The math and analysis only gets you so far... in the end, there is quite a bit of subjectivity in picking the last couple teams, and the determining factor seems to vary year to year, so to exactly match the committee time and again is uncanny.
Appreciate all the comments, I really do. Thanks.
To be fair, I want to reiterate that I've only been perfect selecting the at-larges 3 times in the 23 years I've been doing this. Here are my updated numbers, followed by head-to-head results vs. Lunardi and Palm over the last 5 seasons.
Projecting At-Larges (1991-92 through 2013-14)
1991-92: 33/34
1992-93: 31/34
1993-94: 30/34
1994-95: 30/34
1995-96: 33/34
1996-97: 31/34
1997-98: 30/34
1998-99: 31/34
1999-00: 32/34
2000-01: 34/34 -- perfect --
2001-02: 33/34
2002-03: 33/34
2003-04: 31/34
2004-05: 32/34
2005-06: 31/34
2006-07: 32/34
2007-08: 33/34
2008-09: 34/34 -- perfect --
2009-10: 33/34
2010-11: 35/37
2011-12: 36/37
2012-13: 36/37
2013-14: 36/36 – perfect --
Totals: 750/793 (94.6%)
SelectionSunday At-Large Projections
2009-10: 33/34 (Illinois; Florida in instead)
2010-11: 35/37 (Colorado/Virginia Tech; Georgia/UAB in instead)
2011-12: 36/37 (Seton Hall; Iona in instead)
2012-13: 36/37 (Kentucky; LaSalle in instead)
2013-14: 36/36 – perfect --
Last 5 Years: 176/181 (97.2%)
Since Field of 68: 143/147 (97.3%)
Joe Lunardi (ESPN.com) At-Large Projections
2009-10: 33/34 (Illinois; Florida in instead)
2010-11: 34/37 (Colorado/St. Mary’s/Virginia Tech; Georgia/UAB/VCU in instead)
2011-12: 36/37 (Seton Hall; Iona in instead)
2012-13: 37/37 – perfect --
2013-14: 35/36 (SMU; NC State in instead)
Last 5 Years: 175/181 (96.7%)
Since Field of 68: 142/147 (96.6%)
Jerry Palm (CBSSports.com) At-Large Projections
2009-10: 34/34 -- perfect --
2010-11: 35/37 (St. Mary’s/Virginia Tech; UAB/USC in instead)
2011-12: 35/37 (Northwestern/Seton Hall; Iona/NC State in instead)
2012-13: 36/37 (Tennessee; Middle Tennessee in instead)
2013-14: 35/36 (SMU; NC State in instead)
Last 5 Years: 175/181 (96.7%)
Since Field of 68: 141/147 (95.9%)
Time to go into hibernation for awhile!