Tomes is a very polarizing player. He puts up crazy scoring numbers on a decent Suburban team. The team needs him to score a lot, he averages 35ppg, 4.2 assists. If he was on a balanced stacked team like Tartan, Wayzata, or Maple Grove, he would probably average 18 ppg and 6 assists.
He is the 6th rated player in the state on 247. Let's compare him to the 5th, Jayden Moore out of Hopkins. He also is 6' on a good day. He puts up 18ppg, 4 reb, 9.6 assists. He is a much better athlete. He isn't a shooter, but is a great defender, and a true pg.
Does one take a Jayden Moore and hope he can learn how to shoot? Does one take a Tomes, who can fill it up all over the court, but probably won't be a good defender, will have to learn to set others up more, and adjust his game. Our team next year needing some shooters may have been a factor. Not sure what the status of Moore as a recruit is, and whether he's concentrating on basketball or football.
I think Tomes will be a backup pg for a year or two behind Willis, and Asuma next year. Will there be times he runs of screens like a SG, sure. With his size he will almost always guard a pg. Could a 6-4 athlete shut him down? Sure, buy why would a team with a 6-4 athletic defender put him on a backup-backup pg? And if you do that, is your pg then trying to guard a strong athlete like Reynolds?