You know there were many more questions about Asuma playing in single A competition, although they did play a few bigger schools, on whether he is quick enough, a good enough ball handler, or whether he is a pg. He has been a solid guard.
Tomes is putting up crazy stats against 4A competition, and I'm sure when his team plays a top 5 team, and the main goal is to double him, and let others on his team "beat them", the percentages aren't great. If he is as bad of a recruit as some are making him, he will never be the "man" teams are trying to stop for the gophers. He is the #6 recruit in MN for a reason, in not too deep of a SR class.
I have watched thousands of high schoolers, some deemed projects, some considered to slow, some sure things. Tomes can score against bigger taller athletes, and he has unlimited range.
The question for me is will he buy into defense, and probably become average there? Will he play in Niko's offense, can he work on catch and shoot 3's, can his ego handle maybe playing 7-12 minutes a game next year and maybe only getting 2-3 shots?