maxwellsmart
Member
- Joined
- Nov 10, 2009
- Messages
- 967
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 16
A couple things about Brewster. First off, he did not come in with strong credentials, like Tubby Smith did. Most fans gave him the benefit of the doubt from day one (not guys like Loon or Wren, though.) He talked a great game about going to the Rose Bowl (eventually) but he lost a lot of people with an immediate 1-11 team. Pretty soon, his talk about the players playing a tremendous game fell on deaf ears because it was unrealistic. Minnesota fans will give guys like Tubby a little more leeway because they have respect for him - that respect was earned by a lot of wins and a national championship at Kentucky, one of the top programs in the nation.
I don't think the fans have very much respect for Brewster - he certainly hasn't deserved much so far. I think most fans still don't know whether he can coach or not. I know he can recruit, but so can every other Big Ten coach, and that goes all the way down to Indiana who hauled in some nice pickups. That means you sure as hell better be able to coach in this league or you will wind up in the broadcast booth in a hurry if you can't recruit or coach with the rest of them.
Brewster might have the respect of the players, but in all honesty do did John Gutekunst. The players all backed Gutey as their coach and we lost out on a guy who won a national championship a few years later, Bobby Ross. That was a mistake - Gutey hasn't been a head coach since and Ross was a pretty good coach.
Brewster talks a great game and he can recruit, but he has a lot more in common with Jim Wacker than he does with Lou Holtz, at least so far. His window is starting to close and he will be on the hot seat to start winning very soon, if he isn't already. I am pulling for him to do well as that means the Gophers will be successful, but I don't see him as "our guy." He would leave us the first chance he could for more money and I doubt if he has much loyalty here at all. The rumblings and feelers for the Kansas job backfired and I know the first good team that came after him could get him if they wanted him.
I get the feeling we are really going to know what needs to be done after this year and this will be his make or break season. Either he will be successful and sign a meaningful contract or he will be looking for TE jobs in the NFL again.
If you're statement that he lost a lot of support after the 1-11 season is correct, it says more about the fans we lost than the coach we still have.