IMHO, part of the reason that Pitino got heat for not getting more MN players was this:
If the team is winning, people are less likely to complain.
But if the team is losing, that's when the complaints come out. so, when the team struggled, and the issues with the bench were noted, that's when people hit on the in-state recruiting. I am not saying that having a couple more in-state players on the bench would have made a big difference - but it would have given people one less thing to complain about.
Again, I want the Gophers to sign the best players they can land. But, when it comes to the 6 through 10 guys on the roster, given a choice, I would rather see MN kids there as opposed to some guy from Ohio or wherever.