Tiny, do you remember the guy that you hated so much. In his 2nd year, he brought in some top players. Why couldn't Richard do it. What makes you think that he can from now on?
That was a ridiculous post.
Let's make a comparison:
Tubby year one recruits:
Bostick didn't produce (I liked him but he didn't produce)
Carter transfered
Iverson had an EE career and then transferred and got better
Joseph looked promising and then left
Sampson promising play who ended up a decent Big Ten player
Pitino year one recruits
Martin gone in the blink of an eye
Lofton ditto
Mason really good frosh year
Konate promising big man
Gaston raw athlete- future unknown
Morris about as effective as Carter year one (with different strengths and weaknesses)
verdict year one- I'd say that's a draw
Year 2 Tubby
Cobbs left after a year
Mbakwe great player
White never played
Williams great athlete- good player
Pitino year 2 -three more open schollys but he probably only brings in two more
Jarvis three star big time athlete
Dorsey four start point guard
McBrayer three star with promise as a scorer
Nwankwo athletic but raw big man
If anything I give the edge to Pitino on this class as my guess is that he gets more productivity out of it than Tubby got out of his year two group.
Now you could say..."Hey they haven't even played yet!" and you'd be right. But by the same token you are ridiculous to say that Pitino's year two group has no great players.