- Joined
- Nov 3, 2008
- Messages
- 5,215
- Reaction score
- 1,445
- Points
- 113
What grade would you give the Gophers Fall 2020 recruiting class?
A - they have 5 4-Stars from 247 Sports (4 4-Stars Composite). This is already a solid class even without Dickerson and Schuster.
Oh I see .... it's just a weirdly worded - I guess intentionally mis-worded - way of saying the "early signing period for the 2021 class".
The instate recruiting isn't going well for PJ. Facilities are there, etc etc. I thought he would draw a few of the top guys in.I went with a C, that would be a B if Dickerson ends up eventually signing. Losing your highest rated recruit right before signing day is a gut punch. The lack of in state success on the recruiting trail was shocking. To make matters worse, 1 went to Iowa and 2 to Wisconsin. Flip the Iowa commit to Minnesota and we have the better class. Flip one of the Wisconsin commits to Minnesota and we really close the gap there. Want to make an excuse about in state recruiting for whatever reason? Fine. How about taking one of the highly rated kids from Iowa or Wisconsin that stayed home as a "trade" for the Minnesota kid they got? That puts us above Iowa and closes the gap on Wisconsin too. It's a losing formula to have those schools come in to Minnesota to take talent and then not return the favor. Something has to change there or the ridiculous losses to them (going to try not to use the rivalry word until we earn that) will continue.
I would have liked more than 2 OL in the class. I am a little baffled by taking 4 wr's considering how run heavy we were again this year and I also am only really excited about 1 of the 4 as a prospect personally.
I do like the quality of the recruits everywhere else and the staff did a great job of getting guys from out of state committed site unseen. If this was year 1,2, or 3 and we weren't coming off the best season of my lifetime this would be a B class even without Dickerson. As it stands, it's a C for me based on rising expectations and disappointing instate results.
You’re assuming Iowa and Wisconsin wouldn’t get guys from somewhere else if they didn’t get the MN guys.I went with a C, that would be a B if Dickerson ends up eventually signing. Losing your highest rated recruit right before signing day is a gut punch. The lack of in state success on the recruiting trail was shocking. To make matters worse, 1 went to Iowa and 2 to Wisconsin. Flip the Iowa commit to Minnesota and we have the better class. Flip one of the Wisconsin commits to Minnesota and we really close the gap there. Want to make an excuse about in state recruiting for whatever reason? Fine. How about taking one of the highly rated kids from Iowa or Wisconsin that stayed home as a "trade" for the Minnesota kid they got? That puts us above Iowa and closes the gap on Wisconsin too. It's a losing formula to have those schools come in to Minnesota to take talent and then not return the favor. Something has to change there or the ridiculous losses to them (going to try not to use the rivalry word until we earn that) will continue.
I would have liked more than 2 OL in the class. I am a little baffled by taking 4 wr's considering how run heavy we were again this year and I also am only really excited about 1 of the 4 as a prospect personally.
I do like the quality of the recruits everywhere else and the staff did a great job of getting guys from out of state committed site unseen. If this was year 1,2, or 3 and we weren't coming off the best season of my lifetime this would be a B class even without Dickerson. As it stands, it's a C for me based on rising expectations and disappointing instate results.
You make some really good points. We had the best class in the B1G in the state of Illinois 2 of their top 4 and 3 of top 13. That is where Fleck has the most comfort. Also got a top 10 out of 4 states. Dickerson would be the big get.I went with a C, that would be a B if Dickerson ends up eventually signing. Losing your highest rated recruit right before signing day is a gut punch. The lack of in state success on the recruiting trail was shocking. To make matters worse, 1 went to Iowa and 2 to Wisconsin. Flip the Iowa commit to Minnesota and we have the better class. Flip one of the Wisconsin commits to Minnesota and we really close the gap there. Want to make an excuse about in state recruiting for whatever reason? Fine. How about taking one of the highly rated kids from Iowa or Wisconsin that stayed home as a "trade" for the Minnesota kid they got? That puts us above Iowa and closes the gap on Wisconsin too. It's a losing formula to have those schools come in to Minnesota to take talent and then not return the favor. Something has to change there or the ridiculous losses to them (going to try not to use the rivalry word until we earn that) will continue.
I would have liked more than 2 OL in the class. I am a little baffled by taking 4 wr's considering how run heavy we were again this year and I also am only really excited about 1 of the 4 as a prospect personally.
I do like the quality of the recruits everywhere else and the staff did a great job of getting guys from out of state committed site unseen. If this was year 1,2, or 3 and we weren't coming off the best season of my lifetime this would be a B class even without Dickerson. As it stands, it's a C for me based on rising expectations and disappointing instate results.
B. It's the best in a while but still slightly below average in the conference. I think an A would be for roughly top 3 in the conference and top 10 in the country.
I don’t care what the rankings say, I don’t see how Nebraska has a better class than. It’s simply ranked higher because they signed more guys. Also two of their top five guys are tight ends. Why is everyone worried about the number of oline recruits, if the staff is as worried they will add someone by February. Is the book completely closed on Townley? I still think we are the team to beat for Dickerson for some reason.I went with a C. We finished 8th in the B1G and 4th in the west behind Wisconsin, Iowa and Nebraska. We lost momentum down the stretch, and the last week was nothing short of a disaster with Dickerson not signing and losing out on Townley, Hood and the 5 offensive linemen we were after. 2 offensive linemen isn’t nearly enough in a class, and 1 out of the top 8 Minnesota recruits is embarrassing. We had a great start in the spring but limped into the finish line.
I went with a C. We finished 8th in the B1G and 4th in the west behind Wisconsin, Iowa and Nebraska. We lost momentum down the stretch, and the last week was nothing short of a disaster with Dickerson not signing and losing out on Townley, Hood and the 5 offensive linemen we were after. 2 offensive linemen isn’t nearly enough in a class, and 1 out of the top 8 Minnesota recruits is embarrassing. We had a great start in the spring but limped into the finish line.
Takes time as many have said in previous threads.The instate recruiting isn't going well for PJ. Facilities are there, etc etc. I thought he would draw a few of the top guys in.
In what way is this class slightly below average in the Big Ten? It isn't at the level of Ohio State and Michigan but we are never going to be able to out recruit those guys on paper. But as far as the rest of the conference is concerned this class is right in line with the best in the West division.
By Minnesota standards this class is an A. If Dickerson signs it is an A by any standard, if he doesn't it maybe goes to a high B. This is the kind of class we need to be able to compete in the Big Ten West on a yearly basis.