Only my personal opinion (not trying to sway anyone else) but i recognise that by posting I’m inviting others to pick holes in my argument.
I feel it is difficult to make a judgment on the long term state of the program this year. The lack of pre-season practice time has hit a number of teams/units where the critical mass of starters is new. That has happened to LSUs defense (for example) and it has happened to ours (I recognise there may be exceptions to this).
The new guys on our defense haven’t had the depth of practice time to develop cohesively as a unit - that has showed in every game (to a lesser extent v Illinois as they didn’t have the capacity to take advantage).
Because I don’t think we can take too much from this point in this season. I’m willing to continue to reference back to last. I feel PJ has proven he has the ability to produce winning teams and coach kids up. The 2019 Gophers did not look great the first 3 games, scraping wins against average opponents, but by the time they beat Auburn (benefitting from the extra practices for the Bowl game) they were legit. Our rate of improvement was greater than the norm.
I’m the type of fan that feels, when you have someone with proven ability, coaching continuity and acceptance by the administration/fan base that there will be ups and downs (in any sport) is vital for success.
I acknowledge that PJs style is not for everyone (and that coaching continuity does not sell newspapers) but he has proven he can raise the profile of our program, can achieve 10 wins+ in a power 5 conference and can get his players to buy into a culture academically and morally.