WashedGoph
Active member
- Joined
- Aug 31, 2023
- Messages
- 46
- Reaction score
- 110
- Points
- 33
Safety room is pretty deep at the moment. Probably wanted to be able to get on the field earlier.Was hoping the success of Mohamed Ibrahim would pull him in.
Safety room is pretty deep at the moment. Probably wanted to be able to get on the field earlier.Was hoping the success of Mohamed Ibrahim would pull him in.
Isn't it different now where they're legally bound by signing?It's hard to get invested in the signing class when you know many of them won't be around next year.
think more alluding to the high number that transfer after freshman year and don't stick around to develop if they aren't playingIsn't it different now where they're legally bound by signing?
Team recruiting rankings were mostly worthless before the portal.....they are completely worthless now.All true, but I do think class recruiting rankings are a factor in on field performance. We are at 51 last I looked...so we gotta make it up in the portal or out coach our opponents many who rank well ahead of us in recruiting.
Slotted 15th in the Big Ten Big Ten Rankings
We did seem to recruit a higher rated QB than we typically do. Maybe he is the wild card.
Mindless commentTeam recruiting rankings were mostly worthless before the portal.....they are completely worthless now.
It would actually be really interesting to look at the 2021 or 2022 recruiting classes for teams and see how many of those guys are even on the roster for the team they committed to. I bet the amount of attrition would be off the charts with the way players move around.
Yeah, outside of Karmo and Jackson Kollock, I really don't care about anyone else.It's hard to get invested in the signing class when you know many of them won't be around next year.
There are a million factors but I find this interesting...our recruiting classes annually rank between 30 and 50. And our team at season's end for on field performance slots in somewhere between the 30th and 50th best team.Team recruiting rankings were mostly worthless before the portal.....they are completely worthless now.
It would actually be really interesting to look at the 2021 or 2022 recruiting classes for teams and see how many of those guys are even on the roster for the team they committed to. I bet the amount of attrition would be off the charts with the way players move around.
Huh?Isn't it different now where they're legally bound by signing?
Average class ranking is 6th all time here for PJ and lower than last year. It’s sub par for HS recruits but can be made up for with transfers.Disagree
Unless I'm misunderstanding, they're now signing legally binding financial aid documents.Huh?
Plus last year we lost a kid to Clemson, he signed with them, then portaled here after Clemson spring ball.
To be clear when I say they are worthless I am talking more about saying a team has the 35th best class or is 15th best in their conference. There are tiers to be sure.There are a million factors but I find this interesting...our recruiting classes annually rank between 30 and 50. And our team at season's end for on field performance slots in somewhere between the 30th and 50th best team.
Yet, the teams that annually recruit at a TOP 25 level are the teams in the Top 25 level. The same teams get the best portal additions. Sure, there are exceptions, but the teams in the playoff picture are Top 25 recruiting teams....so it matters. To say it doesn't is silly.View attachment 34920View attachment 34921
Isn't that what they were doing before?Unless I'm misunderstanding, they're now signing legally binding financial aid documents.
As per Ryan Burns write up:Isn't that what they were doing before?
Abu technically goes to Heritage Christian, but plays football for Providence. Heritage co-ops with Providence for football.MN High School Players Expected Landing Spots (BOLD P4)
43 Total Players
23 to the Missouri Valley Conference
7 to St. Thomas
Aidan Adamski, Hermantown: St. Thomas
Ryan Babatz, Buffalo: North Dakota State
Jack Bauer, Eastview: St. Thomas
Malachi Boadi, Minnetonka: St. Thomas
Trey Boyd, Shakopee: Northwestern
Chase Brixius, Benilde-St. Margaret’s: North Dakota State
Michael Bruggers, Champlin Park: Air Force
Khalif Brown, Benilde-St. Margaret’s: North Dakota State
Carter Carstens, Chanhassen: St. Thomas
Ethan Cole, Chatfield: North Dakota
Max Coles, Shakopee: South Dakota
Damian Devine, Holy Angels: North Dakota State
Luke Emmerich, Monticello: Wisconsin
Chase Evink, Hancock: North Dakota State
Sebastyen Fries, Lakeville North: South Dakota State
Kyle Frendt, East Ridge: Wyoming
Colin Hansen, Byron: Minnesota
Nathan Hromadka, Maple Grove: North Dakota
Dylan Hudgens, Minnetonka: South Dakota
Abdul Jinadu, Champlin Park: Drake
Elijah Johnson, Fairmont: St. Thomas
Emmanuel Karmo, Cooper: Minnesota
Charles Langama, Maple Grove: North Dakota
Frank McAninch, Mankato West: North Dakota
Brody Miller, Shakopee: South Dakota State
Michael Naber, Shakopee: St. Thomas
Damarius Russell, Waseca: South Dakota State
Elijah Rumph, Eden Prairie: Western Kentucky
Luke Ryerse, East Ridge: Minnesota
Blake Schiltz, Pine Island: North Dakota State
Graysen Schneider, Stewartville: Montana State
Trillion Sorrell, Edina: South Dakota State
Ethan Stendel, Caledonia: Minnesota
Meyer Swinney, Edina: California
Abu Tarawallie, Providence Academy: Minnesota
Owen Thiegels, Moorhead: North Dakota
Beau Thielen, Eagan: St. Thomas
Theo Thomas, Totino-Grace: Northern Iowa
Dylan Vokal, Maple Grove: North Dakota State
Gavin Wang, Annandale: North Dakota State
Josh Wedel, Chaska: South Dakota State
Jacob Wrbanek, Maple Grove: North Dakota State
Josiah Young, Totino-Grace: Northern Iowa
Been there, done that.
Does this mean that for the B1G, a scholarship is only guaranteed for one year vs all four years?As per Ryan Burns write up:
Prospects will no longer sign national letters of intent — which have existed for 60 years — but will now sign binding financial aid agreements with universities. However, signing the new piece of paper will have the same binding qualities to a university and likely will include contract details once revenue sharing begins next academic year. The financial aid agreement will also bind transfers to universities, prohibiting other schools from contacting and "flipping" transfers after they sign.
Burns mentioned it was a trade off so that coaches can have time off without worrying about losing recruits.As per Ryan Burns write up:
Prospects will no longer sign national letters of intent — which have existed for 60 years — but will now sign binding financial aid agreements with universities. However, signing the new piece of paper will have the same binding qualities to a university and likely will include contract details once revenue sharing begins next academic year. The financial aid agreement will also bind transfers to universities, prohibiting other schools from contacting and "flipping" transfers after they sign.
Pretty sure it has been that way for a while.Does this mean that for the B1G, a scholarship is only guaranteed for one year vs all four years?
Hopefully it works. Seems like anything that restricts player movement at all these days has been stripped away. Would love to see some sort of actually enforceable contract of some kind but not holding my breath.Burns mentioned it was a trade off so that coaches can have time off without worrying about losing recruits.
What color is the sky in your world, lol.Restore the old portal/transfer rules
Yeah, as much as it would be great to see some of the old rules put in place (especially sitting out a year if you aren't a grad transfer) those days are long gone.What color is the sky in your world, lol.