TonyLiebert
Well-known member
- Joined
- Aug 18, 2020
- Messages
- 569
- Reaction score
- 1,149
- Points
- 93
Correct.Im not getting used to this supposedly "normal" attrition!!!
It's not the portal, per se; it's the one free transfer policy.Sad - not sure we will ever see college football again like you and I remember. Unless the NCAA retracts this piece of s… called the portal, we/I will never really enjoy college athletics again. Sorry…
Sad - not sure we will ever see college football again like you and I remember. Unless the NCAA retracts this piece of s… called the portal, we will never really enjoy college athletics again. Sorry…
The reason I love college sports is the influx of new talent each year with normal attrition. Unfortunatley outside factors have taken it over. I will continue to make college sports my game of choice. I'm guessing by the passion of your posts so will you.Sad - not sure we will ever see college football again like you and I remember. Unless the NCAA retracts this piece of s… called the portal, we/I will never really enjoy college athletics again. Sorry…
I may be in the minority but I kind of like the chaos of the transfer portal. Sure it sucks to see a guy like Ky Thomas leave but on the flip side of that I don't get hung up on guys like Burns leaving because I don't get attached to players until after they prove they can actually play at the college level. Recruiting is fun to follow but it is silly to get wrapped up in any recruit until you see if they can cut it at the college level. Because there are tons of high rated guys that can't and low rated guys that can.Damn. This sucks. I was hoping he would stay, but I wish a few others did too. This is getting out of control. Very hard to build consistency and a "developemental" program. I guess its possible to improve the players that leave with better players in theory. But its hard to be a fan of an incoming freshman thinking he'll be around for awhile and represent the U well, not knowing if a particular game will be his last.
Perhaps. Still have Finnessy and Lindenberg. Which kind of reinforces my idea that local recruits are far less likely to transfer.This new portal reality makes college FB a year-round sport to pay attention to.
There will be exits from the program but Fleck has proven that he can transfer in some ready-to-go talent that has helped the Gophers in the last few seasons.
I hope for the best for Burns wherever he lands.
But looking at the LBs in his recruiting class, with Tank Brown and Burns leaving it seems like MN missed the mark that year at that position.
Get over yourself.Sad - not sure we will ever see college football again like you and I remember. Unless the NCAA retracts this piece of s… called the portal, we/I will never really enjoy college athletics again. Sorry…
I enjoyed our defensive line this year which was significantly boosted by transfers. Maybe the best Gopher DL of my lifetime.Sad - not sure we will ever see college football again like you and I remember. Unless the NCAA retracts this piece of s… called the portal, we/I will never really enjoy college athletics again. Sorry…
I see what you did there. Good one.I was bummed about Ky, but this one burns.
There has to be competition ahead of him. It is both a good thing and a bad thing. Players have to be re-recruited every year. Many have aspirations of being a starter.Had high hopes for him due to him coming from IMG and having good offers. However, he only played three games this year. I think recruiting rankings and competing offers are fun to get excited about, but after 2-3 years in the program, it probably makes sense to trust our coaching staff that they are playing the guys they feel give us the best chance to win (an argument otherwise is silly, IMO).
I'll make a few assumptions about this situation. Burns knows MSM is coming back and will be on the field - but you don't transfer because of one super senior ahead of you. Burns knows that Oliver is recovered from his injury and is shaping into a star with multiple years left. Burns knows that Willis was getting legit playing time at the last half of the year. Burns knows that Lindenberg played ahead of him in 2020. Burns knows that Devon Williams had a good redshirt year. The kid has an idea of where he stands in relation to these players (not to mention Finnessy and Aune). I certainly wouldn't feel I had a guaranteed spot in the Top 4 LBs if I were him.
All that said, I'm not going to get upset about highly-regarded players who weren't seeing the field leaving as I'd rather trust the coaches know what they are seeing in practice and the offseason. Also, I think PJ has done well in the portal, so it's hard to gripe too much about an outgoing player when we don't yet know who we might get coming to us.
I enjoyed our defensive line this year which was significantly boosted by transfers. Maybe the best Gopher DL of my lifetime.
Dylan Wright was our most explosive WR when not randomly disappearing.
Jack Gibbens was a rock for the U at linebacker.
Wait until you see Dr. Quinn Carroll out there in 2024!
Minnesota would have been a little weaker this year without portal.
Puns are needed in these trying times.I was bummed about Ky, but this one burns.
It is a giant musical chair. Some will be left with no seats when the music stops.Right. Seems like the portal is going to be a "win some/lose some" type thing. So far.....I'd say that the Gophers are still quite a bit ahead.