Man, I'd take every single one of these guys. Some turned out better than others but every single one of these players was/is at least a rotation player in a power conference (other than Dainja and Holmgren who haven't played yet but I'm sure they'll be at least that good)Going back to 2014 (according to 247):
Holmgren 5Suggs 5Garcia 4Dainja 4Carlson 4Walton 4Hurt 5Nnaji 4Terry 4Jones 5Oturu 4Sims 4Reuvers 4Davison 4Thompson 4Coffey 4Jones 5Travis 4Macura 4
That being said, there are plenty of other issues to solve other than in-state recruiting. If we recruit well out of state and coach well, the in-state won't matter.
Looking at that list is still painful though.