Answering my own question, Gophers brought in Chavez, Oakland, & Krapf in a short period, now no new players of comparable talent this year. How can a program progress at this slow rate? The bottom half of the batting order produces nothing and no new top national level pitching talent out of high school since Fiser 8 years ago. The program is stagnating without better recruiting.
Piper knows that recruiting pitching talent is top priority, so it’s not for lack of trying. If she gets the talent in here, she won’t waste it. But the elephant in the room, so to speak, since her hire has been whether she and her staff can identify AND recruit talent at a level approaching what Allister did — because that is the level required to become and remain nationally relevant.
There’s no sugarcoating it — this has historically been a tough place to be nationally relevant. I think the conference gaining strength will help some, but cold-climate softball programs aren’t for everybody.
That said, the right coach can do it. We saw it first-hand, and some of us may have been lulled into thinking just making the tournament was the floor for this program. It’s not.
Piper cares tremendously about this program. She was here before Allister came and set the wheels in motion for its rise to prominence. She does not want to be known as the coach that oversaw its descent back into mediocrity. But the jury is out on her ability to convince the players — particularly pitchers — needed to win at a high level to come here.
As a Minnesota fan, the frustrating thing is that Piper‘s track record as a pitching coach stacks up against anyone in the country. You would think that alone would be enough to get prominent pitchers interested in joining this program. But unfortunately, to date, other than Pease as a transfer, and the enigmatic Leavitt, she just hasn’t been able to do it.
Maybe one of the freshman pitchers will have an epiphany and suddenly start shutting teams down. But ace-level promise usually shows itself fairly early with dominance over opponents we should dominate, and we just haven’t seen anything close to that out of any of them yet.
For those of you starting to call for a change in the head coach position, I think you’ll need to wait at least two more seasons. If at that time a clear downward trend has been established, Coyle might consider letting Piper go. Maybe. She has earned some slack for all she has done for Gopher softball as both a player and a coach. I hope that doesn’t happen, because I like Piper and what she has given to this program. But I also want to be a fan of a nationally relevant program again.
We are losing right now, primarily because our record in one-run games is so atrocious. Hope we can right the ship in the next two weeks. There are still opportunities for some high-profile wins to gain some confidence and have a successful season.