The Whalen hire was a grand slam her first season. She was a superstar and delivered that high-profile presence. Unfortunately, the program came undone, and she didn't have coaching experience to lead it a different way. The new coach is really good, like really good.
Motzko turned the Gophers hockey program around, earning him tremendous respect in the hockey community. Then he made questionable decisions during the upset loss to Quinipiac in the championship game.
Based on championships, the Coyle era is a flop. But there's a lot more to it. I think everyone would agree that the athletic department seems extremely well run. The video, image, and professionalism is tops. This is a huge university with a lot going on. It's a big job.
Volleyball faced a NIL wave, the last coach to me bailed at the the peak, and then their best player's ability disappeared. I see volleyball's struggles as partly structural. The Penn States and Nebraskas of sports have a NIL operations advantage. And Wisconsin. And...
Women's hockey last season had a pro-caliber team but were upset in the Frozen Four against the eventual champion. They have a phenom player coming in two seasons, a huge get. At some point they need to win another championship. It's like men's hockey, a strong program for the university but where's the trophy.
Gymnastics seems to be better than par.
We are observing wrestling that faces teams with big NIL advantages. So far wrestling has stabilized this season. Sadly, NIL is a real threat to take out that program. So far they are holding.
Men's basketball is complicated. The program hit rock bottom. You can say that Johnson's coaching doesn't look very good during game, or you can say his guys are coming along and check back next season -- a painful journey that is paying off.
I'm not an activist and don't want to be dragged into the issue of affirmative action either way. I will say it would bother me if nearly every single head coach was white. I mean, come on. It's like we're color blind and we're against bigotry, but gosh they're almost all white, how did that happen. Therefore I have to say I like Ben Johnson a lot personally and maybe people should stick it out one more season. His guys ARE coming along.
Minnesota has a lopsided female enrollment. The scholarships mirror that. The scholarships are for the students, not fans. Kids about to graduate high school and then going to school to play sports are what those are for, and no you shouldn't have to be a boy to play sports. Yes, the scholarships are for the kids. I know some people didn't like men's gymnastics getting cut. I say, who cares. The sports first are for the kids to play.
The football program is a big success. As long as they stay in the middle of the pack, it will be the gravy train. They're not a national championship team, and that's fine. As long as they compete respectably without any of the scandals of past decades, it's a win.
Minnesota structurally has been at a disadvantage with NIL. It's a major problem. I see lots of attention with Dinkytown Athletics, so progress maybe has been made.
Has Coyle been successful depends on what criteria you want to use.