BYU QB Reportedly Transferring



His claim is the most byu thing ever

He admitted to sex which is an honor code violation which is why he’s getting suspended and why he’s transferring
 

His claim is the most byu thing ever

He admitted to sex which is an honor code violation which is why he’s getting suspended and why he’s transferring
Yeah, OP kind of buried the lead. Apparently he isn't facing criminal charges for the alleged assault which he claims was consensual but is getting suspended for 7 games for having pre-marital sex.......I get the whole religious school angle but wow that seems way over the top. Gotta think that honor code makes it much tougher to get non Mormons to transfer in.
 

Yeah, OP kind of buried the lead. Apparently he isn't facing criminal charges for the alleged assault which he claims was consensual but is getting suspended for 7 games for having pre-marital sex.......I get the whole religious school angle but wow that seems way over the top. Gotta think that honor code makes it much tougher to get non Mormons to transfer in.
Given it’s only come up a few times in decades, I’d envision they do an awful lot of looking the other way
 


Given it’s only come up a few times in decades, I’d envision they do an awful lot of looking the other way
I would assume it is made very clear to players to keep their extra curricular activities private :)

Ratzlaff didn't really have a choice in this one as he had to admit the sex happened in his defense of it not being assault.
 

Yeah, OP kind of buried the lead. Apparently he isn't facing criminal charges for the alleged assault which he claims was consensual but is getting suspended for 7 games for having pre-marital sex.......I get the whole religious school angle but wow that seems way over the top. Gotta think that honor code makes it much tougher to get non Mormons to transfer in.
Correct. I took the headline off the net but messed up the paraphrasing.
 

https://sports.yahoo.com/article/sources-byu-qb-jake-retzlaff-232320032.html

The quarterback faces a civil lawsuit from a woman who said he “raped, strangled and bit” her in his bedroom after she and a friend visited him and his roommates the night of Nov. 22, 2023, to play video games and hang out. The lawsuit seeks more than $300,000 in damages for each of three causes of action “to be proven at trial.”
 

Maybe he can go to Nebraska where they use to have a whole roster of players not honoring the code of conduct (maybe they didn't have one).
 




https://sports.yahoo.com/article/sources-byu-qb-jake-retzlaff-232320032.html

The quarterback faces a civil lawsuit from a woman who said he “raped, strangled and bit” her in his bedroom after she and a friend visited him and his roommates the night of Nov. 22, 2023, to play video games and hang out. The lawsuit seeks more than $300,000 in damages for each of three causes of action “to be proven at trial.”
I'm (obviously) not a lawyer, and I probably failed social studies class.

Shouldn't this be a criminal case, not a civil one? Or can (almost?) every criminal case also be a civil one? Why have a duplicate set of laws?
 

I'm (obviously) not a lawyer, and I probably failed social studies class.

Shouldn't this be a criminal case, not a civil one? Or can (almost?) every criminal case also be a civil one? Why have a duplicate set of laws?
yes, you are obviously not a lawyer....google it.
 

I'm (obviously) not a lawyer, and I probably failed social studies class.

Shouldn't this be a criminal case, not a civil one? Or can (almost?) every criminal case also be a civil one? Why have a duplicate set of laws?
Legal Gopher here to help. The "victim" (only in quotations for the sake of a label, I am not doubting the claims made here) can file in civil court, criminal court, or both. If the V had wanted to file for criminal charges in additional charges as well, but Utah's statute of limitations for the charge can limit when V wants to charge it. If V wants criminal charges for r*pe, then it could be charged whenever but in Utah for SA, it needs to be reported within 4 years and charged within 8. If the civil lawsuit goes through and she is successful, then V can also ask for charging documents to be filed for criminal charges. If V was worried that criminal charges may be unsuccessful (idk what Utah law looks like for civil charges for this happening or what their SA charge looks like), V may have wanted to wait to see if civil charge was a win before charging criminally
 




Legal Gopher here to help. The "victim" (only in quotations for the sake of a label, I am not doubting the claims made here) can file in civil court, criminal court, or both. If the V had wanted to file for criminal charges in additional charges as well, but Utah's statute of limitations for the charge can limit when V wants to charge it. If V wants criminal charges for r*pe, then it could be charged whenever but in Utah for SA, it needs to be reported within 4 years and charged within 8. If the civil lawsuit goes through and she is successful, then V can also ask for charging documents to be filed for criminal charges. If V was worried that criminal charges may be unsuccessful (idk what Utah law looks like for civil charges for this happening or what their SA charge looks like), V may have wanted to wait to see if civil charge was a win before charging criminally
This isn't correct. The state (or county), not the victim, brings a criminal action. That's why criminal cases are captioned "State of Minnesota vs. Accused Person." I don't know why there are no criminal charges here, but there are circumstances where the victim of an alleged sexual assault would like the matter pursued but the state declines to do so. This can be based on all sorts of reasons like not believing that a crime occurred, lack of evidence, a belief that a conviction is unlikely, etc. While less common, there are also instances where the state pursues a criminal action over the objections (or without the cooperation) of the alleged victim.

She can decide to pursue the civil action against Retzlaff, she doesn't get to decide to when or if criminal charges are pursued.
 




Top Bottom