I don't quite see how Tucker getting a drinking violation and getting kicked off the team would hurt the schools reputation (Unless it could hurt the teams academic standing - not sure?)? UCONN just won a national title amid NCAA violations (ya know, cheating) and the media can't stop their Jim Calhoun / UCONN love fest.
If anything, it shows the U giving Tucker a second (third) chance and if it doesn't work, Tucker is the failure (not the school) and the U looks generous IMO, for giving a chance to a hometown kid who had some issues. If he succeeds, even better, sounds like a Big10: The Journey story.
I don't want him to have a scholarship considering he doesn't deserve it over anyone on the team right now, but if he wants to walk-on at his home school and improve his life. I am okay with that, one wrong move though and say good-bye, if he really wants to end his problems with alcohol tell him his status on the team is conditional on going to rehab and staying clean. One minor slip up and the experiment has to be over.
I just watched the "Run Ricky Run" 30 for 30 on ESPN, turn-around stories can happen if a guy is motivated and gets the correct help.