Sportsfan24
Active member
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2009
- Messages
- 12,686
- Reaction score
- 8
- Points
- 36
Hows that for a title?
GG, that’s what I’m going to call you if you don’t mind…eloquently and rightfully called me out on being vague in criticisms of Kill and the program. You even went through the trouble of digging up some examples (you cherry picked but I would have too…smile).
Here are my issues with Kill, Dr. “Kervorkian” Smith and Ed “Ice your leg” Lochrie.
To the parent of one of the medical department folks, you were right I should have called a pig a pig and not inadvertently indicted everyone associated…especially my hopefully still good buddy Chris.
Kim broke his leg, Doc Smith botched the surgery (was later corrected by a doctor I hired), Ed and Doc wouldn’t listen to Kim telling him something was drastically wrong (Brewster era). Only to be followed by Kim recovering from surgery (Kill era), suffering a “pulled” groin, being shot up every week to mask the pain, again telling Fred Flintstone…excuse me Ed that something was drastically wrong (which was later corrected by the leading Dr in his field who…you guessed it… I hired) and asking coach Kill to take a day off from practice because….you know making all those tackles on a “pulled” groin can be kind of taxing only to be told “no practice no play”….now get out there on special teams and sprint 50 yards and then play defense and make double digit tackles. He didn’t actually say the last part but you get my drift.
The “pulled” groin turned out to be a completely torn on one side and almost completely torn on the other side groin tear…which led to a stress fracture in his other leg (the one he didn’t break) that required major surgery (by a Dr….which I hired) and…..wait for it….another rod.
Botched surgery, missed diagnoses which led to more surgeries. You would think that coach would go to bat for his player when scouts look at film and are wondering why his star (my words…in the Kill system the S leads the Big Ten in tackles by design…his words) player is looking like he just got off a horse after a 200 mile ride while running around in the secondary? Nope, never mentioned it, but he did tell said scout how tough his job was and how little talent he was left with. Really? Why the –uck would he care? He was just interested in that productive little S you had that appeared to have a hitch in his giddy up. The NFL talent evaluator (the ones who initially assign grades) knew NOTHING about any of this so I can imagine that any scout who made a phone call to coach was told nothing either. He was solely evaluated on his “film.”
By the way I don’t totally fault Kill for this, I should have been telling anyone and everyone that walked by what they did or didn’t do, but instead I was actually trying not to make anyone look bad (hey…I’m not perfect). As one of the asst coaches (blog again and I will call you out by name) who pose as a blogger stated “keep it in the program,” which is a valid point as long as the “program” is reciprocating and taking care of the player.
Now in fairness (I hate my personal code of ethics sometimes) like I said in the AJ situation, Kill was operating under the assumption that Beavis and Butthead knew what they were doing and responded accordingly (which still doesn’t excuse him for not “fighting” for his player).
Speaking of AJ Barker; doesn’t this have a striking similarity with the AJ situation? Medical staff misdiagnosing player, player not trusting them and getting pissed of and having a heated exchange and the coach responding without having all the info, the player assuming coach does and he just doesn’t care?
Here is what I have to say to that….AJ, coach Kill, both of you were right and both of you were wrong. Makeup and move forward. Teague….you better replace these idiots (Gomer and Goober Pyle) before the U gets sued or worse.
Too harsh? Not when nobody calls to see if you made it out of surgery alive (the last one in May, the rest he still had eligibility so of course they called).
And while I’m clearing my soul; the hillbilly comment I made came from a NFL person who said the staff reminded him of the tv show “the Beverly Hillbillies.” because they come across as not belonging and in way over their heads in their interactions with NFL folk. I wouldn’t or couldn’t go that far (say they don’t belong) but IMO some of them are completely uncomfortable with grown-ups. Too harsh? I can see that; I apologize.
With all of that being said; I still believe if coach grows into ALL aspects of this job he will be successful. I want him to be successful because I am a U fan and nothing that happened with Kim will ruin his life…I would argue he will be better for it because the strongest steel is forged from the hottest fire. That doesn’t however mean I can’t point out things I’m unhappy about or dislike the folks who I believe caused it, (hell some of you get mad at me because I don’t like the freaking football coach.)
There it ALL is GG; like I said, there is nothing here for someone else to dislike certain folks but I think you would agree there is stuff here to justify or at the least explain why I may not feel all warm and cuddly about some folks.
For the rest of you, going forward can you now take what I say at face value? I have no agenda, I just like to talk sports and like each one of you it’s from my own perspective.
This was around a 1000 words (way under AJ’s 4000) so none of you had better refer to it has a manifesto!
GG, that’s what I’m going to call you if you don’t mind…eloquently and rightfully called me out on being vague in criticisms of Kill and the program. You even went through the trouble of digging up some examples (you cherry picked but I would have too…smile).
Here are my issues with Kill, Dr. “Kervorkian” Smith and Ed “Ice your leg” Lochrie.
To the parent of one of the medical department folks, you were right I should have called a pig a pig and not inadvertently indicted everyone associated…especially my hopefully still good buddy Chris.
Kim broke his leg, Doc Smith botched the surgery (was later corrected by a doctor I hired), Ed and Doc wouldn’t listen to Kim telling him something was drastically wrong (Brewster era). Only to be followed by Kim recovering from surgery (Kill era), suffering a “pulled” groin, being shot up every week to mask the pain, again telling Fred Flintstone…excuse me Ed that something was drastically wrong (which was later corrected by the leading Dr in his field who…you guessed it… I hired) and asking coach Kill to take a day off from practice because….you know making all those tackles on a “pulled” groin can be kind of taxing only to be told “no practice no play”….now get out there on special teams and sprint 50 yards and then play defense and make double digit tackles. He didn’t actually say the last part but you get my drift.
The “pulled” groin turned out to be a completely torn on one side and almost completely torn on the other side groin tear…which led to a stress fracture in his other leg (the one he didn’t break) that required major surgery (by a Dr….which I hired) and…..wait for it….another rod.
Botched surgery, missed diagnoses which led to more surgeries. You would think that coach would go to bat for his player when scouts look at film and are wondering why his star (my words…in the Kill system the S leads the Big Ten in tackles by design…his words) player is looking like he just got off a horse after a 200 mile ride while running around in the secondary? Nope, never mentioned it, but he did tell said scout how tough his job was and how little talent he was left with. Really? Why the –uck would he care? He was just interested in that productive little S you had that appeared to have a hitch in his giddy up. The NFL talent evaluator (the ones who initially assign grades) knew NOTHING about any of this so I can imagine that any scout who made a phone call to coach was told nothing either. He was solely evaluated on his “film.”
By the way I don’t totally fault Kill for this, I should have been telling anyone and everyone that walked by what they did or didn’t do, but instead I was actually trying not to make anyone look bad (hey…I’m not perfect). As one of the asst coaches (blog again and I will call you out by name) who pose as a blogger stated “keep it in the program,” which is a valid point as long as the “program” is reciprocating and taking care of the player.
Now in fairness (I hate my personal code of ethics sometimes) like I said in the AJ situation, Kill was operating under the assumption that Beavis and Butthead knew what they were doing and responded accordingly (which still doesn’t excuse him for not “fighting” for his player).
Speaking of AJ Barker; doesn’t this have a striking similarity with the AJ situation? Medical staff misdiagnosing player, player not trusting them and getting pissed of and having a heated exchange and the coach responding without having all the info, the player assuming coach does and he just doesn’t care?
Here is what I have to say to that….AJ, coach Kill, both of you were right and both of you were wrong. Makeup and move forward. Teague….you better replace these idiots (Gomer and Goober Pyle) before the U gets sued or worse.
Too harsh? Not when nobody calls to see if you made it out of surgery alive (the last one in May, the rest he still had eligibility so of course they called).
And while I’m clearing my soul; the hillbilly comment I made came from a NFL person who said the staff reminded him of the tv show “the Beverly Hillbillies.” because they come across as not belonging and in way over their heads in their interactions with NFL folk. I wouldn’t or couldn’t go that far (say they don’t belong) but IMO some of them are completely uncomfortable with grown-ups. Too harsh? I can see that; I apologize.
With all of that being said; I still believe if coach grows into ALL aspects of this job he will be successful. I want him to be successful because I am a U fan and nothing that happened with Kim will ruin his life…I would argue he will be better for it because the strongest steel is forged from the hottest fire. That doesn’t however mean I can’t point out things I’m unhappy about or dislike the folks who I believe caused it, (hell some of you get mad at me because I don’t like the freaking football coach.)
There it ALL is GG; like I said, there is nothing here for someone else to dislike certain folks but I think you would agree there is stuff here to justify or at the least explain why I may not feel all warm and cuddly about some folks.
For the rest of you, going forward can you now take what I say at face value? I have no agenda, I just like to talk sports and like each one of you it’s from my own perspective.
This was around a 1000 words (way under AJ’s 4000) so none of you had better refer to it has a manifesto!