Tubby picked up Mav in about May of 2010, when we had just had a different point guard, Justin Cobbs, transfer about a month before and needed to fill the spot, and pickings are a bit slim this time of year. If Dre transfers in a couple days and Pitino signs a 2-star point guard because he is the best attainable option at this point, are you going to criticize his recruiting?
Also not sure if you're implying that Mo is untalented or simply out of shape, but he was a Rivals top 150 recruit with multiple BCS offers, so it's not like he was some guy that no one wanted that Tubby recruited on a whim. I agree it would be to Mo's benefit to drop a little weight and get in better shape, but having sustained an injury that sidelined him for the better part of 2 seasons has slowed his development.
Personally I still think there's hope for Oto, he had an okay freshman year. I don't believe it was until this season that the "Oh God, why is this guy on the floor?" sentiment became common.
More Tubby apologist drivel. Please move to the TT board. Poor Tubby, lost recruits because of transfers and had to fill the positions with non-Big Ten athletes!