All Things 2025 Minnesota Vikings Off-Season Thread

[gophersfan]

Your point is fair.

I should have added to the ideal backup criteria list: is not trying to be a starter!


Lot of people think that instantly removes Cousins and Rodgers from the list. I agree for Cousins, I think he still have enough juice and now he will not be only a year removed from Achilles rupture ... he just wasn't the same physically last year. I'm not as sure for Rodgers. If he deices to roll the dice by passing on Pittsburgh ... where else is left? He has one year left in the tank. A ring with half a season or less of physical wear and tear is worth more than a full season of wear and tear and probably no ring. My opinion

Rodgers: $10M or less, one year. Primary role mentor. If McCarthy falters and/or tweaks the injury, then he can come in and be the hero. This is a Super Bowl built team. Win now.

Sign it

Come on dude. We just traded for Sam Howell to be the got damn backup to JJ McCarthy. Aaron Rodgers is not coming to Minnesota. End of the story. Now can you move on from Aaron Rodgers and get him off this thread.

 

[GopherGrit]

Rodgers has plenty of money. He's not going anywhere to be a backup/mentor.

If I follow you correctly, you're saying a thing like "he has so much money, he doesn't need to take a non-start job".

I'm saying a thing like "he has so much money ... he doesn't need to do anything. He can just well retire. But what would actually be a worthwhile proposition for him to not do that?"


I could well be shown wrong, but I think a ring -- even if he wasn't the starter for most of the season -- is a more inciting proposal than being the starter on a team that has no realistic shot at the Super Bowl this coming season.

He could be our Nick Foles.

 

[GopherGrit]

You're presuming the Vikings would want Rodgers for that role.

I don't think they would, assuming good health for the current QBs on the roster.

I'm wild guessing mind you, but I think the reason the Rodgers to Vikings drama played out so long, is that they were having serious discussion behind closed doors.

I believe Rodgers has come out and said that he pitched a $10M salary and being a mentor to McCarthy to the Vikings. But I think at that time he was pitching that as a way to be the starter for this year's team, and they ultimately decided to say no to that.


I'm saying, the same exact pitch, but as the (primary) backup. And again, just for 2025. Win now. He could be our Nick Foles. Meaning that, Philly does not win the Super Bowl without him, even though he was not the starter.

I don't see how a reasonable, level-headed person turns it down. The people turning that down are the hateful people ... "he'll be a cancer" and all that crap ... they have a right to that opinion, but I strongly disagree with

 

[GopherWeatherGuy]

I'm wild guessing mind you, but I think the reason the Rodgers to Vikings drama played out so long, is that they were having serious discussion behind closed doors.

I believe Rodgers has come out and said that he pitched a $10M salary and being a mentor to McCarthy to the Vikings. But I think at that time he was pitching that as a way to be the starter for this year's team, and they ultimately decided to say no to that.


I'm saying, the same exact pitch, but as the (primary) backup. And again, just for 2025. Win now. He could be our Nick Foles. Meaning that, Philly does not win the Super Bowl without him, even though he was not the starter.

I don't see how a reasonable, level-headed person turns it down. The people turning that down are the hateful people ... "he'll be a cancer" and all that crap ... they have a right to that opinion, but I strongly disagree with

The Vikings are built similarly to how the Chiefs were in Mahomes 2nd season, which was his first as a starter. They ended up being a 1 seed and losing to the Patriots in the AFC championship game. Mahomes then won the Super Bowl the following season. You know who the backup QB was? Chad Henne who hadn't started a game in 4 years.

Howell is a capable backup who still has upside. He can win games. NFL teams don't want Rodgers because he's old, washed up, and he brings a media circus to town in the same way most teams don't want to be on Hard Knocks.

Aaron Rodgers will never be a Viking so it's time to move on. The top 3 QBs on the roster next season will be JJ, Howell, and Brosmer.

 

[Ope3]

I don't see how a reasonable, level-headed person turns it down. The people turning that down are the hateful people ... "he'll be a cancer" and all that crap ... they have a right to that opinion, but I strongly disagree with

A reasonable level headed person can determine Rodgers has not had a decent season since 2021. The Packers got better after he left. The Jets won more games without him in 2023 than with him in 2024.

40 year old QBs not named Tom Brady just don't lead NFL Teams to Super Bowls.

 

[coolhandgopher]

I'm wild guessing mind you, but I think the reason the Rodgers to Vikings drama played out so long, is that they were having serious discussion behind closed doors.

I believe Rodgers has come out and said that he pitched a $10M salary and being a mentor to McCarthy to the Vikings. But I think at that time he was pitching that as a way to be the starter for this year's team, and they ultimately decided to say no to that.


I'm saying, the same exact pitch, but as the (primary) backup. And again, just for 2025. Win now. He could be our Nick Foles. Meaning that, Philly does not win the Super Bowl without him, even though he was not the starter.

I don't see how a reasonable, level-headed person turns it down. The people turning that down are the hateful people ... "he'll be a cancer" and all that crap ... they have a right to that opinion, but I strongly disagree with

Feels like this is a bit you’re running into the ground now. I don’t think anyone can presume to get into Aaron Rodgers head and if one thing has been demonstrated by him over the last several years is he doesn’t have the humility to quietly step into a backup/advisor role for a young QB.

 

[Just Gopher It!!]

If I follow you correctly, you're saying a thing like "he has so much money, he doesn't need to take a non-start job".

I'm saying a thing like "he has so much money ... he doesn't need to do anything. He can just well retire. But what would actually be a worthwhile proposition for him to not do that?"


I could well be shown wrong, but I think a ring -- even if he wasn't the starter for most of the season -- is a more inciting proposal than being the starter on a team that has no realistic shot at the Super Bowl this coming season.

He could be our Nick Foles.

Gritty how you won’t take your L

 

[TNGophfan]

If I follow you correctly, you're saying a thing like "he has so much money, he doesn't need to take a non-start job".

I'm saying a thing like "he has so much money ... he doesn't need to do anything. He can just well retire. But what would actually be a worthwhile proposition for him to not do that?"


I could well be shown wrong, but I think a ring -- even if he wasn't the starter for most of the season -- is a more inciting proposal than being the starter on a team that has no realistic shot at the Super Bowl this coming season.

He could be our Nick Foles.

Think you are totally missing the issue and Rodgers mindset. Again, for the 30th time among people on here. He's not coming unless he's promised the starting job. It's why talk with him fizzled.

 

[GopherGrit]