I think it was the 2010 class that I was referring to, the one with Austin, Elliot, Mo, Mav, Chip, and Oto, but yes, I did say that. The entire class is not comparable, no, which maybe I should have clarified. I was referring to the spring signings of that class, Mo excluded. Austin and Elliot were both fall recruits as I recall. Mo signed in April 2010, possibly as an attempt by Tubby to help lure Cory Joseph, but even if signing Mo failed to do that, he was a top 150 recruit with multiple BCS offers, and I don't believe he was someone we took because we were scrambling for players.
I think Mav and Chip, and maybe Oto to a lesser extent, were spring recruits signed to fill needs that came up in the spring and didn't exist in the fall, when we assumed Paul Carter and Justin Cobbs would be returning.
Pitino is also signing players in the spring for needs that he did not have in the fall because he was at FIU. In that respect, that is, signing spring recruits to fill spring needs, I think Pitino's 2013 class and the last half/third of Tubby's 2010 class are similar. I'm not even upset about this class, McNeil and Mathieu seem legit, Smith is a senior so I'm hoping he'll be solid if only because he seems like a decent shooter and has experience in Pitino's system. The only one I have some reservations about is King, as it sounds like did decent but didn't set the world on fire in a lesser conference, but then few players have really great seasons in their freshman year, so maybe I'm just being too hard on him.
So I don't even think this class is that bad, especially for the amount of time Pitino had to recruit, but I could see where some posters would probably not be happy with Tubby having a recruiting class of let's say Alvin Ellis, a JuCo, a MVC transfer, and a Conference USA transfer.