This 3 man class of McNeil, Mathieu, and King reminds me so much of the 2010 group of Maverick, Oto, Mo, and Chip.
How so? McNeil, as you mentioned, should make an impact in the future. Dre Mathieu should also play a role right away - he had offers from Memphis, UCLA, Ole Miss, and other high-majors. Why you are frustrated that Pitino brought in a highly-regarded JUCO? As for King...Joey's a guy that fills a need (PF). Yes, he's not your ideal recruit, but it's June.
Can you have Joey, Oto, and JP on a press and run "athletic roster" ? That's really tough, especially if Mo and Elliott are still around.
That's two years from now; you're thinking way too far ahead.
This team needs impact guys
Every team wants impact guys.
This team needs impact guys, not guys who project as role players and I am not sure some on the board understand how far behind we are falling in regards to the level of recruits we are bringing in compared to our conference peers.
Let's compare our 2013 recruiting class to our rivals' classes. Pitino really hasn't done that bad considering when he arrived and how much time he's had.
Wisconsin
Vitto Brown - good, but his offer list isn't any better than Mathieu or McNeil's.
Riley Dearring - Tubby didn't even look at Dearring hard. Meh.
Nigel Hayes - only high-major offers were Ohio State, Wisconsin, and Minnesota - not any better than Mathieu or Mcneil's offer list.
Jordan Hill - second and third best offers were Lehigh and Florida Gulf Coast. Yikes.
Bronson Koenig - very talented and the gem of Wisconsin's class
All in all, I'd say McNeil, Mathieu, King, and Smith make up a class about equal to Wisconsin's.
Iowa
Peter Jok - Iowa and Drake were Jok's only offers. However, Jok is pretty talented; he certainly lit up Roseville at the T-Wolves Shootout.