Perhaps, but you realize it is possible that no one on the Selection Committee has watched an actual game all season. They do not need to watch or enjoy basketball to read printouts. I suspect many posters here do not actually enjoy the games. Some may not watch many.No one should be a slave to a computer index but computer indexes are better than humans for:
1) arranging general rankings among a very large group of objects around objective criteria;
2) being able to provide general consensus.
As long as the criteria on those indexes are transparent, understandable, and consistent people can adjust to them.