WSJ: Arch Manning Is the Biggest College Quarterback Prospect Ever. Finally, He’s Getting the Keys.

BleedGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
63,393
Reaction score
21,360
Points
113
Per the Wall Street Journal:

Like any wise grandkid, Arch Manning knows:

Grandpa’s going to say what grandpa’s going to say.

Grandpa in this case is Archie Manning, Arch’s beloved namesake, quarterback paterfamilias, Ole Miss legend, Saints martyr, father to Cooper, Peyton and Eli—and a proud septuagenarian who can’t help but occasionally stir it up with a public comment.

Earlier this month, Archie was quoted in Texas Monthly saying that his 21-year-old grandson—at last, the starting No. 1 quarterback for the University of Texas Longhorns—would keep his college eligibility and not enter next spring’s NFL draft, despite predictions that he, like uncles Peyton and Eli, could be taken No. 1 overall.

“Arch isn’t going to do that,” Archie said. “He’ll be at Texas.”

Gramps’s proclamation caused a tremor in Austin and the NFL. It came as news to many people—including Arch.

“I don’t know where he got that from,” Arch said later. “He texted me and apologized about that.”

Maybe Arch is being the good grandchild, covering for his chatty grandpops. Maybe Archie’s right when he says the plan is to stay in school—that’s what Peyton and Eli did—and he simply jumped the gun on the news.

The freakout was a perfect encapsulation of the unusual life of Arch Manning, perhaps the most talked-about, swooned-over college football QB prospect ever.

On one hand is that incredible QB bloodline, three NFL pros, two College Hall of Famers, four Super Bowl rings, too many TV commercials to count. It’s often said that Cooper, the eldest of Archie’s three sons, was the best athlete of the Manning brothers, a star receiver forced to quit the game after spinal stenosis surgery.

On the other hand is the public’s familiarity and fascination—and more than a little invasiveness. Everyone knows the Manning family. Or thinks they do.

The Mannings—led by Cooper and wife Ellen Heidingsfelder—have done their best to shield Arch from the chaos. Like his father and uncles, Arch attended Isidore Newman School in New Orleans, where a few of his games would wind up on ESPN, but his adolescence was as maintained as “normally” as possible.


Go Gophers!!
 



Biggest in name maybe, but he’s nowhere near the best prospect to ever come out of high school, and he won’t be the biggest ever coming out of college.
I agree with that but I do think there's a pretty good chance he becomes a starting NFL quarterback.
 

I agree with that but I do think there's a pretty good chance he becomes a starting NFL quarterback.
Don’t get me wrong he’s good, potentially great, but he’s nowhere near the prospect that Andrew Luck, Trevor Lawrence and others were at this stage. Heck he’s probably not the biggest prospect named Manning. Not a knock on him, just a knock on the hyperbole from the author.
 



Per the Wall Street Journal:

Like any wise grandkid, Arch Manning knows:

Grandpa’s going to say what grandpa’s going to say.

Grandpa in this case is Archie Manning, Arch’s beloved namesake, quarterback paterfamilias, Ole Miss legend, Saints martyr, father to Cooper, Peyton and Eli—and a proud septuagenarian who can’t help but occasionally stir it up with a public comment.

Earlier this month, Archie was quoted in Texas Monthly saying that his 21-year-old grandson—at last, the starting No. 1 quarterback for the University of Texas Longhorns—would keep his college eligibility and not enter next spring’s NFL draft, despite predictions that he, like uncles Peyton and Eli, could be taken No. 1 overall.

“Arch isn’t going to do that,” Archie said. “He’ll be at Texas.”

Gramps’s proclamation caused a tremor in Austin and the NFL. It came as news to many people—including Arch.

“I don’t know where he got that from,” Arch said later. “He texted me and apologized about that.”

Maybe Arch is being the good grandchild, covering for his chatty grandpops. Maybe Archie’s right when he says the plan is to stay in school—that’s what Peyton and Eli did—and he simply jumped the gun on the news.

The freakout was a perfect encapsulation of the unusual life of Arch Manning, perhaps the most talked-about, swooned-over college football QB prospect ever.

On one hand is that incredible QB bloodline, three NFL pros, two College Hall of Famers, four Super Bowl rings, too many TV commercials to count. It’s often said that Cooper, the eldest of Archie’s three sons, was the best athlete of the Manning brothers, a star receiver forced to quit the game after spinal stenosis surgery.

On the other hand is the public’s familiarity and fascination—and more than a little invasiveness. Everyone knows the Manning family. Or thinks they do.

The Mannings—led by Cooper and wife Ellen Heidingsfelder—have done their best to shield Arch from the chaos. Like his father and uncles, Arch attended Isidore Newman School in New Orleans, where a few of his games would wind up on ESPN, but his adolescence was as maintained as “normally” as possible.


Go Gophers!!
No pressure at all on the young man.
IMG_0439.jpeg
 

Some of the forgotten ones. Wasn’t Jimmy Clausen pretty high prospect? Also think Robo Qb out of USC had to be near the best Qb prospect. Matt Barkley was another one.
 




Some of the forgotten ones. Wasn’t Jimmy Clausen pretty high prospect? Also think Robo Qb out of USC had to be near the best Qb prospect. Matt Barkley was another one.
Wasn't Vince Young a perfect 1.00 prospect (as opposed to the rare .99, .98's that you sometimes see).

Good list though. Forgot about Clausen.
 


Some of the forgotten ones. Wasn’t Jimmy Clausen pretty high prospect? Also think Robo Qb out of USC had to be near the best Qb prospect. Matt Barkley was another one.
Clausen was massively hyped because he so very much looked the part

Trevor Lawrence was another one

John David Booty also had a huge amount of hype coming out of HS
 

Clausen was massively hyped because he so very much looked the part

Trevor Lawrence was another one

John David Booty also had a huge amount of hype coming out of HS
Just thought of Mitch Mustain from Arkansas. Wasn't he also top-notch? Then 4 years later he was sitting in jail on national signing day, if I remember correctly.
 



Wasn't Vince Young a perfect 1.00 prospect (as opposed to the rare .99, .98's that you sometimes see).

Good list though. Forgot about Clausen.
Yes Vince Young was high up there started slow then once beating Michigan in the Rose Bowl never looked back. The other poster who mentioned Trevor Lawrence yeah he was great from the start.
 


Yes Vince Young was high up there started slow then once beating Michigan in the Rose Bowl never looked back. The other poster who mentioned Trevor Lawrence yeah he was great from the start.
i think, at least the way I took it, is that the article is saying he is the most hyped prospect ever. Some of those pan out, some don't. Lawrence was viewed as a can't miss future NFLer/HOF type QB in HS. He definitely looked the part for the most part in college
 

Lawrence was viewed as a can't miss future NFLer/HOF type QB in HS. He definitely looked the part for the most part in college
Yeah, after beating Saban's defense as a true freshman, I figured he'd go #1 when eligible. I didn't think he'd struggle this much though. Maybe he didn't learn enough just sitting there in the shot gun all the time?
 

Yeah, after beating Saban's defense as a true freshman, I figured he'd go #1 when eligible. I didn't think he'd struggle this much though. Maybe he didn't learn enough just sitting there in the shot gun all the time?
My worthless opinion, I'd say it's intelligence level. Ton's of physical characteristics, but .......
 

Yeah, after beating Saban's defense as a true freshman, I figured he'd go #1 when eligible. I didn't think he'd struggle this much though. Maybe he didn't learn enough just sitting there in the shot gun all the time?
Some guys just can’t adjust to the speed/processing and the jags being ass for forever did not help his development.
 




Top Bottom