I'll bet you are wrong.
Here's the funny thing. A guy completes 18 of 30 passes for 225 yards, no picks. Is that a good day or a great day? Statistically, it's a great day for college QB (123), pretty average for a pro (83). The average college fan expects their QB to be a pro and will bitch about the 12 incompletions.
In that same scenario, the difference between a 50% passer and a 60% passer is 3 completions.
Joe Namath was an absolute sh!t quarterback, but every one loved him because he made one prediction and it came true. It's the ONLY reason he's in the HOF. It's more a love/hate/tolerance thing--and winning--than a statistical one...