We can and should be better. I would guess that we were ranked higher when there was universal agreement in the state about the importance of making education a funding priority.
University of Minnesota Campus
- Thread starter HoustonTXGopher
- Start date
We can and should be better. I would guess that we were ranked higher when there was universal agreement in the state about the importance of making education a funding priority.
Section2
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2009
- Messages
- 56,053
- Reaction score
- 9,074
- Points
- 113
I thought we were talking about the MN University system.
https://smartasset.com/student-loans/top-states-higher-education
This ranks us 30 for our state U system. I mean, it's not bad, but nothing to brag about. We start with the smartest students in high school, great test scores, and our University system takes that and spits out #30.
This is all besides the point. jammer isn't able to argue without non sequiturs.
Section2
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2009
- Messages
- 56,053
- Reaction score
- 9,074
- Points
- 113
Cruze
Well-known member
- Joined
- May 12, 2017
- Messages
- 2,433
- Reaction score
- 295
- Points
- 83
The top states to get an education in America in 2017
Companies and states agree: The most important factor in deciding where to set up shop these days is a smart, skilled workforce. And one of the best ways to develop that workforce is education.
In our America’s Top States for Business study, the Education category spans kindergarten through college and beyond and is worth a possible 200 out of 2,500 points. You can see our complete methodology and sources here. This year these states move to the head of the class — America’s smartest states for 2017.
10. PENNSYLVANIA
The Keystone State vaults into the smartest states, thanks to a marked improvement in high school test scores last year. Recognizing the importance of a skilled workforce, Pennsylvania has become a leader in what are known as STEM ecosystems — collaborations between schools, businesses and communities to encourage science, technology, engineering and math learning. The state still faces challenges, however, seriously lagging the rest of the nation in funding its state colleges and universities.
2017 Education score: 133 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 256
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.1/SAT: 1487
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 16
2016 Education rank: No. 21
9. IOWA
Iowa is another state that did some studying over the summer. The Hawkeye State turned in the best high school test scores in the nation last year. While state support for higher education ranks in the top half nationally, Iowa’s commitment appears to have been wavering in recent years, with funding coming in below the state Board of Regents’ requests. As a result, students and their families have faced three straight years of tuition hikes. Recognizing the growing importance of computer science — and the critical shortage of IT workers in the state — Iowa is one of only a handful of states to have implemented computer science standards beginning in kindergarten.
2017 Education score: 138 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 64
Average test scores: ACT: 22.1/SAT: 1785
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 17
2016 Education rank: No. 17
8. NEW HAMPSHIRE
What the Granite State lacks in size, it makes up for in academic strength. Durham-based Dartmouth College is respected worldwide. The state could do better in supporting its public post-secondary institutions, but students in public K–12 schools come away well prepared to compete in the 21st-century workforce. The state’s NH Goes First Plan aims to make the state a leader in “competency-based education,” starting with pre-kindergarten and going beyond college, to develop the workforce of the future.
2017 Education score: 142 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 27
Average high school test scores: ACT: 24.5/SAT: 1568
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 2
2016 Education rank: No. 11
7. VERMONT
The Green Mountain State carefully cultivates its K–12 schools, with the nation’s highest per-pupil spending and smallest class sizes. More important, the care pays off with some of the best student performance in the country. Vermont takes pride in keeping its students on the cutting edge. A 2015 state survey found more computers than students in the public schools. All of that lavish attention seems to trail off after high school, however. The state lags the nation in support for higher education.
2017 Education score: 143 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 9
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.4/SAT: 1541
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 4
2016 Education rank: No. 7
5. (tie) NEW YORK
The Empire State reigns almost supreme in support for public education at all levels, and that is based on figures compiled before the state adopted Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s ambitious plan to offer free tuition to many middle-income students at state colleges and universities. Based on outcomes, however, the state could do a better job of targeting where the money is spent. Of course, this has a lot to do with the large population, but high school test scores barely crack the top half of the states, and elementary school math and reading scores are in the bottom tier.
2017 Education score: 147 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 304
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.9/SAT: 1467
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 34
2016 Education rank: No. 8
5. (tie) NEBRASKA
Nebraska ranks in the top five nationally in increasing support for higher education over the past five years, but that may be about to change. Colleges and universities across the Cornhusker State are adopting tuition increases to make up for deep cuts in state funding. That is bad news for some of the best-prepared high school graduates in the nation. Performance on standardized tests in high school and elementary school is consistently strong.
2017 Education score: 147 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 16
Average high school test scores: ACT: 21.4/SAT: 1758
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 9
2016 Education rank: No. 9
4. NEW JERSEY
Despite living in a big and populous state, New Jersey students enjoy a surprising degree of individualized attention in school. Only tiny Vermont offers smaller class sizes. New Jersey ranks in the top five nationally for per-pupil spending and parlays that into the third best performing elementary school students. That edge may be in jeopardy, however, since outgoing Gov. Chris Christie has been keeping education funding flat. Already, the state’s higher-education system is hurting for resources due to dwindling state support.
2017 Education score: 151 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 72
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.1/SAT: 1501
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 3
2016 Education rank: No. 6
3. CONNECTICUT
You can’t spell this state’s name without the word “connect” — appropriate, because Connecticut’s schools are now among the most connected in the nation. The state has committed to connecting every classroom to the internet and has made major strides in the past year. The Nutmeg State sprinkles lots of money on its public school system and has some of the nation’s best test scores to show for it. Higher education can be uneven, however. This may be the home of Yale University, but state schools, like the University of Connecticut, are starving for support.
2017 Education score: 154 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 43
Average high school test scores: ACT: 24.5/SAT: 1747
Elementary math & reading rank: No.10
2016 Education rank: No. 18
2. MINNESOTA
It turns out some of the nation’s best-performing high school graduates, but it does so with characteristic Midwestern thrift — the state does not rank in the top 10 for school spending. Gov. Mark Dayton has made education funding a priority, however. Spending has been steadily increasing on his watch, though not as much lately as many would prefer. Class sizes are larger than in most states, but beleaguered Minnesota teachers may soon get reinforcements. The legislature recently passed licensing reforms aimed at easing a chronic teacher shortage.
2017 Education score: 156 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 115
Average high school test scores: ACT: 21.1/SAT: 1815
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 5
2016 Education rank: No. 2
1. MASSACHUSETTS
What else would you expect from the place where American higher education was invented with the founding of Harvard University in 1636? Massachusetts has taken that heritage and has run with it. The state’s elementary school students are the best performing in the nation. High school graduates are in the top five. Harvard may be the crown jewel of higher education in the Bay State, but Massachusetts also takes care of its public universities, with state support up nearly 13 percent in the last five years. The state could do a better job modernizing and digitizing its classrooms, but with a tradition dating back to the 17th century, some things take time.
2017 Education score: 168 out of 300 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 124
Average high school test scores: ACT: 24.8/SAT: 1553
Elementary math & reading rank: No.1
2016 Education rank: No.1
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/07/11/the-top-states-to-get-an-education-in-america-in-2017.html
Companies and states agree: The most important factor in deciding where to set up shop these days is a smart, skilled workforce. And one of the best ways to develop that workforce is education.
In our America’s Top States for Business study, the Education category spans kindergarten through college and beyond and is worth a possible 200 out of 2,500 points. You can see our complete methodology and sources here. This year these states move to the head of the class — America’s smartest states for 2017.
10. PENNSYLVANIA
The Keystone State vaults into the smartest states, thanks to a marked improvement in high school test scores last year. Recognizing the importance of a skilled workforce, Pennsylvania has become a leader in what are known as STEM ecosystems — collaborations between schools, businesses and communities to encourage science, technology, engineering and math learning. The state still faces challenges, however, seriously lagging the rest of the nation in funding its state colleges and universities.
2017 Education score: 133 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 256
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.1/SAT: 1487
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 16
2016 Education rank: No. 21
9. IOWA
Iowa is another state that did some studying over the summer. The Hawkeye State turned in the best high school test scores in the nation last year. While state support for higher education ranks in the top half nationally, Iowa’s commitment appears to have been wavering in recent years, with funding coming in below the state Board of Regents’ requests. As a result, students and their families have faced three straight years of tuition hikes. Recognizing the growing importance of computer science — and the critical shortage of IT workers in the state — Iowa is one of only a handful of states to have implemented computer science standards beginning in kindergarten.
2017 Education score: 138 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 64
Average test scores: ACT: 22.1/SAT: 1785
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 17
2016 Education rank: No. 17
8. NEW HAMPSHIRE
What the Granite State lacks in size, it makes up for in academic strength. Durham-based Dartmouth College is respected worldwide. The state could do better in supporting its public post-secondary institutions, but students in public K–12 schools come away well prepared to compete in the 21st-century workforce. The state’s NH Goes First Plan aims to make the state a leader in “competency-based education,” starting with pre-kindergarten and going beyond college, to develop the workforce of the future.
2017 Education score: 142 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 27
Average high school test scores: ACT: 24.5/SAT: 1568
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 2
2016 Education rank: No. 11
7. VERMONT
The Green Mountain State carefully cultivates its K–12 schools, with the nation’s highest per-pupil spending and smallest class sizes. More important, the care pays off with some of the best student performance in the country. Vermont takes pride in keeping its students on the cutting edge. A 2015 state survey found more computers than students in the public schools. All of that lavish attention seems to trail off after high school, however. The state lags the nation in support for higher education.
2017 Education score: 143 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 9
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.4/SAT: 1541
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 4
2016 Education rank: No. 7
5. (tie) NEW YORK
The Empire State reigns almost supreme in support for public education at all levels, and that is based on figures compiled before the state adopted Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s ambitious plan to offer free tuition to many middle-income students at state colleges and universities. Based on outcomes, however, the state could do a better job of targeting where the money is spent. Of course, this has a lot to do with the large population, but high school test scores barely crack the top half of the states, and elementary school math and reading scores are in the bottom tier.
2017 Education score: 147 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 304
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.9/SAT: 1467
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 34
2016 Education rank: No. 8
5. (tie) NEBRASKA
Nebraska ranks in the top five nationally in increasing support for higher education over the past five years, but that may be about to change. Colleges and universities across the Cornhusker State are adopting tuition increases to make up for deep cuts in state funding. That is bad news for some of the best-prepared high school graduates in the nation. Performance on standardized tests in high school and elementary school is consistently strong.
2017 Education score: 147 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 16
Average high school test scores: ACT: 21.4/SAT: 1758
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 9
2016 Education rank: No. 9
4. NEW JERSEY
Despite living in a big and populous state, New Jersey students enjoy a surprising degree of individualized attention in school. Only tiny Vermont offers smaller class sizes. New Jersey ranks in the top five nationally for per-pupil spending and parlays that into the third best performing elementary school students. That edge may be in jeopardy, however, since outgoing Gov. Chris Christie has been keeping education funding flat. Already, the state’s higher-education system is hurting for resources due to dwindling state support.
2017 Education score: 151 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 72
Average high school test scores: ACT: 23.1/SAT: 1501
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 3
2016 Education rank: No. 6
3. CONNECTICUT
You can’t spell this state’s name without the word “connect” — appropriate, because Connecticut’s schools are now among the most connected in the nation. The state has committed to connecting every classroom to the internet and has made major strides in the past year. The Nutmeg State sprinkles lots of money on its public school system and has some of the nation’s best test scores to show for it. Higher education can be uneven, however. This may be the home of Yale University, but state schools, like the University of Connecticut, are starving for support.
2017 Education score: 154 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 43
Average high school test scores: ACT: 24.5/SAT: 1747
Elementary math & reading rank: No.10
2016 Education rank: No. 18
2. MINNESOTA
It turns out some of the nation’s best-performing high school graduates, but it does so with characteristic Midwestern thrift — the state does not rank in the top 10 for school spending. Gov. Mark Dayton has made education funding a priority, however. Spending has been steadily increasing on his watch, though not as much lately as many would prefer. Class sizes are larger than in most states, but beleaguered Minnesota teachers may soon get reinforcements. The legislature recently passed licensing reforms aimed at easing a chronic teacher shortage.
2017 Education score: 156 out of 200 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 115
Average high school test scores: ACT: 21.1/SAT: 1815
Elementary math & reading rank: No. 5
2016 Education rank: No. 2
1. MASSACHUSETTS
What else would you expect from the place where American higher education was invented with the founding of Harvard University in 1636? Massachusetts has taken that heritage and has run with it. The state’s elementary school students are the best performing in the nation. High school graduates are in the top five. Harvard may be the crown jewel of higher education in the Bay State, but Massachusetts also takes care of its public universities, with state support up nearly 13 percent in the last five years. The state could do a better job modernizing and digitizing its classrooms, but with a tradition dating back to the 17th century, some things take time.
2017 Education score: 168 out of 300 points
Number of degree-granting institutions: 124
Average high school test scores: ACT: 24.8/SAT: 1553
Elementary math & reading rank: No.1
2016 Education rank: No.1
https://www.cnbc.com/2017/07/11/the-top-states-to-get-an-education-in-america-in-2017.html
Last edited:
cncmin
Well-known member
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2008
- Messages
- 22,855
- Reaction score
- 7,088
- Points
- 113
Good thread. Most college campuses are beautiful places. Of the campuses that I have ever visited, I can think of exactly zero - big schools or small - that I ever thought were not generally aesthetically pleasing places to be (compared to their surroundings). That includes places such as the University of Pittsburgh, Carnegie Mellon, Minnesota, Michigan State, Iowa State, Virginia Tech, Notre Dame, Stanford, Penn State, Lehigh, Minnesota State, South Dakota State...they all seem to be great in their own way.
That said, there are certainly aspects of the University of Minnesota campus that - especially prior to Yudof - were lacking in aesthetics compared to other campuses. The U seems to try, in some cases, to be more "urban" or unique than it has to be, including the Washington footbridge, a lot of the West campus buildings, the Weisman museum, and others. Furthermore, the rail station and some of the industrial buildings that ran just alongside campus have always been sore spots. The original vision that extended the Mall to the river was indeed spectacular. Someday I hope the U goes there.
That said, there are certainly aspects of the University of Minnesota campus that - especially prior to Yudof - were lacking in aesthetics compared to other campuses. The U seems to try, in some cases, to be more "urban" or unique than it has to be, including the Washington footbridge, a lot of the West campus buildings, the Weisman museum, and others. Furthermore, the rail station and some of the industrial buildings that ran just alongside campus have always been sore spots. The original vision that extended the Mall to the river was indeed spectacular. Someday I hope the U goes there.
Last edited:
Section2
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2009
- Messages
- 56,053
- Reaction score
- 9,074
- Points
- 113
#2!! Wow, we are amazing. I’m sure that’s not correlated with demographics at all.
Now, can you explain why our state university system has fallen to #30? We take 2nd ranked kids and spit them out in 30th place?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Last edited:
It beats private roads every time.
Section2
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2009
- Messages
- 56,053
- Reaction score
- 9,074
- Points
- 113
Very original! You should add “pretzel” just to complete the cliche.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
HoustonTXGopher
Well-known member
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2014
- Messages
- 2,374
- Reaction score
- 964
- Points
- 113
Wow, these are magnificent! Whomever let the U move in any other direction than what was drawn here should rot in hell. These plans were amazing!
HoustonTXGopher
Well-known member
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2014
- Messages
- 2,374
- Reaction score
- 964
- Points
- 113
My wife and I love seeing college campuses. The architecture of the classroom buildings is typically telling of how old the campus is. Great to see the athletic facilities...the football stadiums at some schools like Alabama, LSU and Oklahoma are centerpieces of the campus. And finally, the greek houses intrigue me and are quite unique in different regions of the country.
It doesn't have to be original, deuce. It has to be correct.
Bad Gopher
A Loner, A Rebel
- Joined
- Nov 20, 2008
- Messages
- 23,308
- Reaction score
- 10,573
- Points
- 113
Cass Gilbert is the serial victim of mall-us interruptus. His state capitol grounds were cut off by I-94. That'd be another opportunity for a land bridge someday. You might have noticed that, when they rebuilt the John Ireland Blvd bridge in the late 80's they included an irrigated turf median to provide at least some vegetative corridor to the cathedral.
Ski U Mah Gopher
Member of the Tribe
- Joined
- Nov 12, 2008
- Messages
- 7,899
- Reaction score
- 1,205
- Points
- 113
MNSCU is primarily Community Colleges. There are 30 2-year colleges and 7 4-year universities. The student mix might have something to so with the ranking.
stocker08
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2009
- Messages
- 39,293
- Reaction score
- 23,725
- Points
- 113
It's okay for deuce to say that every government entity is overfunded and underperforming and the free market would do it better. Yay generalizations.
But for that same reason....throwing an outrageously stupid idea like private highways....that he still stands by....in his face is completely fair game.
Sent from my SM-N960U using Tapatalk
Last edited:
Section2
Well-known member
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2009
- Messages
- 56,053
- Reaction score
- 9,074
- Points
- 113
5 factors
1-Percent of state high school graduates attending an in-state public university or college (full weight). For this metric, we included attendance to a community college.
2-Student-to-faculty ratio of all public, four-year universities and colleges, weighted by total enrollment (full weight).
3-Net price for students receiving financial aid of all public, four-year universities and colleges, weighted by total enrollment (full weight).
4-Graduation rate of all public, four-year universities and colleges, weighted by total enrollment (double weight).
5-20-year return on investment for major four-year universities and colleges, weighted by total enrollment (full weight).