I would love to see a cost/revenue breakdown for each sport.
Because it is my suspicion that the money that the U would save by dropping some sports would not end up putting us ahead in the long run as the PR and overall general image issues and damage that would occur would not make it worth it.
All those who hate football or all big money sports would point to the U's dropping non-revenue sports as a sign that UMn was turning into a football factory that doesn't care about academics anymore, or serving the general Mn public, etc., etc., etc.. We here all know that would all be a bunch of bs, but that doesn't matter, the negative press here in Mn would have a field day with it, Fat Pat and all the others who seem to love to write negative things about the U would drag the issue out as long as they could and get as much negative vibes going as they could.
And just because it wouldn't sway the opinions of any diehards out there doesn't change the fact that its probably not the diehards that Teague and Lou are targeting. Anyone on the fence probably won't like the move. Corporations desire POSITIVE vibes and press and won't support the move. So the amount of savings from dropping any programs better be very significant.
Simple fact of the matter is that the University of Minnesota is one of the largest universities IN THE WORLD. And Minnesotans have always prided themselves for being independent and different and in some sense, SUPERIOR in comparison to other states or regions or universities in how we go about our business and our lives, how we conduct our business and our lives, etc.. In so many ways we were a leader in the civil rights movement, and that includes the civil rights of women, blacks, jews, muslims, gays, lesbians and transsexuals, you name it. All while the south, in general, lagged in these regards. The Big Ten conf is similar in many ways as well. Academically the Big Ten is superior to the SEC as a whole and its not even really that close.
So now we see the SEC putting more and more money into football and showing more and more that it doesn't really even care all that much about other sports, not even basketball, to a point. So is the Big Ten, or more specifically, are Minnesotans all of a sudden going to follow the lead of southerners, or the SEC, and focus all of its attention on a big time revenue sport at the exclusion of other sports?!
No.
Think about it. It's not going to happen. If the U somehow decides to go that route it will be lucky if it comes out even on the deal, with the positive monetary aspects equaling the value of the negative vibes that go along with making such a move. IF there is a positive result, a "barn building a house" effect of sorts, we won't see or recognize this and especially won't be able to point this out to the public as being so obvious that they can't deny it, for a very long time. And so maybe we'd be able to bring back all the sports we dropped in 10 or 20 years, starting each one over, from scratch. All of the local athletes getting ready to graduate will have grown up knowing that they had to go out of state to find a decent Div 1 program to take them in and foster their skills. It's even possible local youth participation in those sports may have suffered from the lack of a local Div 1 school's support. So we'd be adding on sports that we'd likely suck in for quite awhile. We even bother at that point?!
OR, we could push to find support for this 190 mil project, get fb and bb supporters to chip in to help all of the non-revenue sports a little, so that they can help the fb and bb programs at the same time. Doing it this way will only generate mostly positive vibes from the press and the residents of the state who care about such things, in general. Some on the fence folk might jump onboard, and local corporations will like the broad based aspect of the project and how they can use their supporting such a broad based project as PR.
Minnesota is trying to get a future Olympics, 2026 I believe? And its flagship University cutting several non-revenue sports so that it can concentrate on building a bb practice facility is NOT the way to get one of the rarest of opportunities to be given to you.
Other factors, Baseball will never be dropped, and to even mention it is a complete waste of time and puts yourself at risk of being seen as a fool. We just built a new stadium for heaven sakes, it would make us a laughingstock. Baseball gets enough private support from alums and the Twins and its still a Major League sport, so its going to be an untouchable sport for at least 10 to 20 years. We recently built a new facility for the Rowing team, and we probably need the Rowing program for Title IX issues as much as anything else.
The only programs I could see the U possibly being able to drop without too much of a negative result would be both Men's and Women's Tennis and maybe Men's Gymnastics, a team that is currently ranked #5 in the nation. But if those are the only 3, why even bother?! And the U is actually looking at ADDING sports, so that makes dropping other sports even that much more difficult, I would think.
I think the pie in the sky, shoot for the moon approach is the best approach and that it WILL work. Minnesotans like a challenge and often rise up to meet such challenges. Yudof's regime set a big fundraising goal and succeeded in reaching it. We got the new Football Stadium built and the new Baseball Stadium built as well and there were people out there that thought neither would ever transpire. We almost lost our Golf and Gymnastics programs yet people came through and saved those. The money is out there, and a broad based attack trying to get the widest spread of general interest in the project is the best way to make it happen.