Very excited for Pitino's first year. It's probably because basketball teams are smaller, and so getting a few good players can have a big impact in a short amount of time. The way Pitino has been recruiting has made this one of the most exciting basketball off-seasons in quite some time. I'm not nearly as big a critic of Tubby's recruiting as some are, as most of his fall recruits turned out be good contributors, but as far as off-season anticipation goes, it's hard to get super excited over landing mostly 3-stars with a few 4-stars (which I suppose is about what Kill is getting for the football). I mean it's kinda cool to get a commitment from any recruit, but seeing Pitino squaring off against teams like UCLA, Indiana, Syracuse, and Louisville for recruits is exciting. Every couple weeks it seems he offers some new top 50 recruit, in fact off the top of my head I can think of about 4 or 5 different 5-star recruits that the basketball staff is currently pursuing.
Not to discredit Kill, but improvement in the football program seems to be going more slowly but surely, like this year is just another step in the process whereas I think a quick meteoric rise is much more likely in basketball if Pitino is able to land a few of those top shelf recruits he's going after.
Also basketball has simply been better than football every year since I started following the teams in 2007 when Brewster and Tubby were hired. The basketball team has gotten to .500 in conference, made the NCAA tournament multiple times, even winning a game last year, beating down UCLA by 20. The basketball team beats Wisconsin sometimes, has beaten Iowa quite a bit. They've recorded at least one win over a top 10 team each of the last five seasons I think, and gotten two of them in a few of those. They crack the top 25 from time to time. There's just less of a feeling of futility in basketball IMO, it's not a struggle to look at the conference schedule and find a few likely conference wins. I also felt that in the 2009-10 and 2010-11 seasons that we were on the brink of greatness but significant personnel losses held us back. (The 2009-10 team could have won the Big Ten with Royce White and Trevor Mbakwe on the floor.)
Basically progress seems to be a lot slower in football than basketball just by the nature of the two sports, and with how well Pitino seems to be recruiting right now, rapid improvement seems a lot more likely on that front. I did just buy Gopher football season tickets for the first time this morning though, and so I'm very excited to attend my first ever Minnesota/Iowa and Minnesota/Wisconsin football games this year!