PJ does it right. None of your business. Always.
Really? Look at the article you cited. What did Schiano say that updates the fans or the press (or the opponent) about any injured player. Schiano said exactly zero about which players are injured, which ones might play and which ones won't. All he says is that the injured players will get better, some might play before the season ends and that some players are limited somewhat by injuries. The players who normally play will be replaced by less experienced guys if they can't go. He mentioned no names. The reporter then adds the names of players who have been banged up, but there is nothing from Schiano giving any insight into who might play, who might not and who might be limited.
You are right. PJ and Schiano are identical in how openly and extensively they use press conferences to reveal snd discuss the injury status of key players in their respective teams. Silly me!
2nd degree isn't wrong though. Schiano said nothing specific about any of his injured players just very general comments saying some will get better soon and some won't but he didn't give names.
Schiano said enough so that the reporter had a pretty good idea of whom Schiano was speaking. Many people can describe a person without using a name. IMHO PJ doesn’t even do this. He doesn’t name names; he also rarely discusses player injuries in terms (without naming names) that might in any way ease an opponent’s game day prep. But it might just be my impression.
I didn't say they were identical, in fact, I acknowledged that their styles are different. But in terms of substance, they are the same. They say nothing. Any reporter who follows the team has a "pretty good idea" which players have been out, who left the last game with an injury, who's been limping, etc. This reporter didn't discern this from Schiano, he knows it because he's been paying attention.
