Rob Manfred floats MLB realignment with American and National Leagues replaced by East vs. West

Gopher_In_NYC

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 19, 2010
Messages
24,179
Reaction score
16,850
Points
113

The sport of baseball has changed a lot under MLB commissioner Rob Manfred, with the institution of the pitch clock, the infield shift ban, the ghost runner and, starting next year, the automatic ball-strike challenge system. But what he floated on Thursday might be the biggest change yet.

Speaking on WFAN's "The Carton Show," Manfred addressed the possibility of MLB expanding to 32 teams after nearly three decades with 30 teams. The commissioner sounded more than open to the idea, saying there are several cities that want an MLB team.

"When people want your product, you ought to try to find a way to sell it to them," Manfred said. "It's kind of basic."



That's not too new. Manfred has been flirting with the idea of expansion for years and said just a few months ago that he intends to select two cities for expansion before his planned retirement in 2029. It got interesting, however, when Manfred made pretty clear that he intends to realign the league once the two new teams are aboard.

That seems to mean going from the American League and National League to something like an East and West league, much like the NBA and NHL currently use.

Among Manfred's reasons for the change is making travel easier for the players:

"It does a ton for us from a format perspective. You would realign, you would do it along geographic lines, which could alleviate a ton of the travel burden that's on players.
"Remember, we ask our players [to play] 162 times in 186 days. So most of the [time] between 162 and 186 [is] travel, right? So you can eliminate a lot of that travel, make it less burdensome, which would be a great thing in terms of player health and safety."
MLB has been composed of the American League and National League for 125 years. They used to be very distinct leagues, with separate governing systems, rulebooks and umpire crews, but that line dissolved in 2000 under former commissioner Bud Selig to more closely resemble the rest of the sports industry.



Manfred's other pitch is that some playoff series would align better time-wise for fan bases (i.e. East Coast fans not having to stay up late to watch an ALDS game on the West Coast):

"If you play geographically, we get in a postseason. You know, we have those four-window days that I love, right? You get four baseball games in a day. It's awesome. But when you think about the fans in the individual markets, you always end up with, because of the way we're set up, you know, you get Boston versus Anaheim in one of the early rounds. So you're either going to be too late for the fans in Boston or too early.
"So if you realign geographically, you would look more like other sports, where you play up East into the World Series and West into the World Series. And that 10 o'clock game on the West Coast that sometimes is a problem for us becomes a prime-time game on the West Coast for the two teams that are playing. So there's a lot of advantages to it."
Manfred shared a vision of eight divisions of four teams and keeping teams in the same city in separate divisions.


How would that look? To throw out a quick mock-up, let's just say the two expansion cities are Nashville and Portland. If we try to create eight geographically distinct divisions with no teams in the same city while trying to preserve some premier rivalries, we could get something like this:

  • West: Seattle Mariners, Portland, San Francisco Giants, Los Angeles Dodgers
  • Southwest: Los Angeles Angels, San Diego Padres, Las Vegas Athletics, Arizona Diamondbacks
  • South: Texas Rangers, Houston Astros, Colorado Rockies, Kansas City Royals
  • Midwest 1: Minnesota Twins, Milwaukee Brewers, Chicago Cubs, St. Louis Cardinals
  • Midwest 2: Chicago White Sox, Cleveland Guardians, Detroit Tigers, Cincinnati Reds
  • Northeast: New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, Toronto Blue Jays, Pittsburgh Pirates
  • Mid-Atlantic: Washington Nationals, Baltimore Orioles, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies
  • Southeast: Atlanta Braves, Nashville, Tampa Bay Rays, Miami Marlins

Please note: That is absolutely not a serious attempt to create permanent, harmonious divisions for MLB. There are some obvious problems. It's just meant to show how different things could become if Manfred is serious. And condolences to the Pirates if those divisions actually do come to pass.

Here’s him on -

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-media-max-width="560"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Rob Manfred tells <a href="https://twitter.com/CMacWFAN?ref_src=twsrc^tfw">@CMacWFAN</a> that he would like MLB to expand to 32 teams and that the league could realign along geographical lines in eight divisions of four if that happens: <a href="https://t.co/h0Vh4nvmxB">pic.twitter.com/h0Vh4nvmxB</a></p>&mdash; SNY (@SNYtv) <a href="">January 8, 2026</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 


The sport of baseball has changed a lot under MLB commissioner Rob Manfred, with the institution of the pitch clock, the infield shift ban, the ghost runner and, starting next year, the automatic ball-strike challenge system. But what he floated on Thursday might be the biggest change yet.

Speaking on WFAN's "The Carton Show," Manfred addressed the possibility of MLB expanding to 32 teams after nearly three decades with 30 teams. The commissioner sounded more than open to the idea, saying there are several cities that want an MLB team.

"When people want your product, you ought to try to find a way to sell it to them," Manfred said. "It's kind of basic."



That's not too new. Manfred has been flirting with the idea of expansion for years and said just a few months ago that he intends to select two cities for expansion before his planned retirement in 2029. It got interesting, however, when Manfred made pretty clear that he intends to realign the league once the two new teams are aboard.

That seems to mean going from the American League and National League to something like an East and West league, much like the NBA and NHL currently use.

Among Manfred's reasons for the change is making travel easier for the players:



MLB has been composed of the American League and National League for 125 years. They used to be very distinct leagues, with separate governing systems, rulebooks and umpire crews, but that line dissolved in 2000 under former commissioner Bud Selig to more closely resemble the rest of the sports industry.



Manfred's other pitch is that some playoff series would align better time-wise for fan bases (i.e. East Coast fans not having to stay up late to watch an ALDS game on the West Coast):



Manfred shared a vision of eight divisions of four teams and keeping teams in the same city in separate divisions.


How would that look? To throw out a quick mock-up, let's just say the two expansion cities are Nashville and Portland. If we try to create eight geographically distinct divisions with no teams in the same city while trying to preserve some premier rivalries, we could get something like this:

  • West: Seattle Mariners, Portland, San Francisco Giants, Los Angeles Dodgers
  • Southwest: Los Angeles Angels, San Diego Padres, Las Vegas Athletics, Arizona Diamondbacks
  • South: Texas Rangers, Houston Astros, Colorado Rockies, Kansas City Royals
  • Midwest 1: Minnesota Twins, Milwaukee Brewers, Chicago Cubs, St. Louis Cardinals
  • Midwest 2: Chicago White Sox, Cleveland Guardians, Detroit Tigers, Cincinnati Reds
  • Northeast: New York Yankees, Boston Red Sox, Toronto Blue Jays, Pittsburgh Pirates
  • Mid-Atlantic: Washington Nationals, Baltimore Orioles, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies
  • Southeast: Atlanta Braves, Nashville, Tampa Bay Rays, Miami Marlins

Please note: That is absolutely not a serious attempt to create permanent, harmonious divisions for MLB. There are some obvious problems. It's just meant to show how different things could become if Manfred is serious. And condolences to the Pirates if those divisions actually do come to pass.

Here’s him on -

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-media-max-width="560"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Rob Manfred tells <a href="https://twitter.com/CMacWFAN?ref_src=twsrc^tfw">@CMacWFAN</a> that he would like MLB to expand to 32 teams and that the league could realign along geographical lines in eight divisions of four if that happens: <a href="https://t.co/h0Vh4nvmxB">pic.twitter.com/h0Vh4nvmxB</a></p>&mdash; SNY (@SNYtv) <a href="">January 8, 2026</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
I always thought baseball Screwed up by not expanding internationally into the Central/South America/Caribbean markets - it wouldn’t work economically now, but it was relatively close to US and passionate fan bases
 
Last edited:

A better idea is relocating the Florida franchises to the two speculative cities on this list and make things work that way.

Crazy to think that there are many cities out there where expansion is viable. Looking at the markets where NFL/NBA have teams without a MLB franchise, this is the list (not including the two mentioned above): Indianapolis, Jacksonville, Oklahoma City, Memphis, New Orleans, Charlotte, and Salt Lake City. None of those inspire me very much as big league, 81 home games a season except maybe Charlotte/Raleigh. Smarter people than I, not dealing with jet lag, might have more perceptive thoughts than I on this however.

But play this game that the author lays out, there’s a way to adjust into pods with a lot less disruption than his scenario-but the Florida franchises make it all go catty wompus.

Or, basically copy the NFL model, create cross-sports rival cities with that league, if Manfred wants to blow tradition all up (I suspect his ego wouldn’t allow for a copycat of the NFL though). Given my jet lag, I spent some time with this:

West 1
Mariners
Dodgers
Giants
D-Backs

West 2
Athletics
Royals
Rockies
Padres

Central 1
Twins
Brewers
White Sox
Tigers

Central 2
Guardians
Pirates
Orioles
Reds

East 1
Yankees
Red Sox
Marlins
Blue Jays

East 2
Phillies
Mets
Rangers
Nationals

South 1
Braves
Rays
Cardinals
Cubs

South 2
Astros
Angels
Charlotte
Nashville

Still a cluster, and Charlotte gets Portland’s franchise, but 🤷‍♂️

Under the scenario with Portland/Nashville, here’s a pretty painless realignment:
AL West
Mariners
Angels
Athletics
Portland

NL West
Dodgers
Giants
Padres
D-Backs

AL Central
Twins
Royals
White Sox
Tigers

NL Central
Brewers
Cubs
Cardinals
Guardians

AL East
Yankees
Red Sox
Orioles
Blue Jays

NL east
Phillies
Mets
Nationals
Marlins

AL New
Astros
Rangers
Rockies
Rays

NL New
Braves
Nashville
Reds
Pirates

Not perfect, but a lot less effing around with tradition and swapping of leagues.
 

A better idea is relocating the Florida franchises to the two speculative cities on this list and make things work that way.

Crazy to think that there are many cities out there where expansion is viable. Looking at the markets where NFL/NBA have teams without a MLB franchise, this is the list (not including the two mentioned above): Indianapolis, Jacksonville, Oklahoma City, Memphis, New Orleans, Charlotte, and Salt Lake City. None of those inspire me very much as big league, 81 home games a season except maybe Charlotte/Raleigh. Smarter people than I, not dealing with jet lag, might have more perceptive thoughts than I on this however.

But play this game that the author lays out, there’s a way to adjust into pods with a lot less disruption than his scenario-but the Florida franchises make it all go catty wompus.

Or, basically copy the NFL model, create cross-sports rival cities with that league, if Manfred wants to blow tradition all up (I suspect his ego wouldn’t allow for a copycat of the NFL though). Given my jet lag, I spent some time with this:

West 1
Mariners
Dodgers
Giants
D-Backs

West 2
Athletics
Royals
Rockies
Padres

Central 1
Twins
Brewers
White Sox
Tigers

Central 2
Guardians
Pirates
Orioles
Reds

East 1
Yankees
Red Sox
Marlins
Blue Jays

East 2
Phillies
Mets
Rangers
Nationals

South 1
Braves
Rays
Cardinals
Cubs

South 2
Astros
Angels
Charlotte
Nashville

Still a cluster, and Charlotte gets Portland’s franchise, but 🤷‍♂️

Under the scenario with Portland/Nashville, here’s a pretty painless realignment:
AL West
Mariners
Angels
Athletics
Portland

NL West
Dodgers
Giants
Padres
D-Backs

AL Central
Twins
Royals
White Sox
Tigers

NL Central
Brewers
Cubs
Cardinals
Guardians

AL East
Yankees
Red Sox
Orioles
Blue Jays

NL east
Phillies
Mets
Nationals
Marlins

AL New
Astros
Rangers
Rockies
Rays

NL New
Braves
Nashville
Reds
Pirates

Not perfect, but a lot less effing around with tradition and swapping of leagues.
Looks good and I doubt the author of the story, put the time into it that you did.
 

Looks good and I doubt the author of the story, put the time into it that you did.
I think the author was just given the info by Manfred.

I'm convinced American & National Leagues are toast.
 


I think the author was just given the info by Manfred.

I'm convinced American & National Leagues are toast.
Agree, but I get it. The leagues were unique, with their own rules and strategies. That's all done now.

Nashville seems like a foregone conclusion to get a team. I'd love it if they could figure out a way to bring the Expos back to life.
 


Agree, but I get it. The leagues were unique, with their own rules and strategies. That's all done now.

Nashville seems like a foregone conclusion to get a team. I'd love it if they could figure out a way to bring the Expos back to life.

Totally agree on both Nashville as a sure bet as well as resurrecting Montreal. In this political/economic climate, I think that's a long shot for Canada to regain a 2nd franchise.

If I was absolutely forced to wager, I go with Salt Lake City as the 2nd franchise but with extremely low confidence.

Geography is working in their favor.
 








Top Bottom