Maybe we all need to row the boat better.Are you suggesting that signing Max should eliminate concerns one has about PJ? Did anyone think he wouldn’t sign a QB in the portal?
Maybe we all need to row the boat better.Are you suggesting that signing Max should eliminate concerns one has about PJ? Did anyone think he wouldn’t sign a QB in the portal?
Uh, oh. He didn't hand the ball to the ref. I see conflict in our future.I respect his decision. Honestly reminds me a lot of Morgan in stature and style. Not a big guy, looks like maybe a little better athlete. Smooth and quick delivery, very productive in high school and college, stats suggest good accuracy. Strong enough arm. Seems smart, grounded in his interview. A+ Good job PJ
My lord you are still insufferable.His ranking is lower than 8th. It's 10th this morning after two more QBs hit the portal and will likely continue to change.
He wouldn't have commented if it was positive.LOL.
Simple statements of fact are "negative."
Max is now ranked 11 of 75 QBs in the portal. Looks like a very good get for Minnesota.As others have stated, he is ranked 8th out of 42 on the On3 QB portal rankings. AK did not make the list.
https://www.on3.com/transfer-portal/industry/football/2024/?position=qb
View attachment 28762
Definitely a good get and should be able to contribute at a high level in game 1 vs North Carolina.Max is now ranked 11 of 75 QBs in the portal. Looks like a very good get for Minnesota.
NoCan he play in the bowl game
As others have stated, he is ranked 8th out of 42 on the On3 QB portal rankings. AK did not make the list.
https://www.on3.com/transfer-portal/industry/football/2024/?position=qb
The total list is now up to 50 now. I thought maybe AK would sneak in at the bottom. It's not easy to be a starting QB in the B1G. Does anyone know how many D-1 QBs are in the portal? Just interested to know. I do hope he decides to stay on and compete for the starting or backup job in 2024-2025. People get hurt all the time. Maybe he can learn some things from another four year starter (Tanner being the first). He could still transfer next year.Max is now ranked 11 of 75 QBs in the portal. Looks like a very good get for Minnesota.
Overall you might have a point. This year if we changed coaching staffs with our opponents for game prep and game coaching we probably win 3 more games. He had a pathetic year.Actually, he did. He could have told AK that he was still his QB next year and things will be better. Certain faction here is convinced they know more than Fleck because, after all, he's just a used car salesman spouting B.S. Then, when PJ shows he might have a bit more substance than that, they still continue to look for chickenshit stuff.
And I get pissed as anyone over losing to Iowa and Wisconsin over the years or blowing a 3 touchdown lead to Northwestern in the last quarter or watching a series of runs up the middle. But if you can't see this guy isn't the best chance of us having a competitive program since God knows when you're either an idiot or you're letting a dislike of PJ's schtick blind you.
Wouldn't surprise me at all from the big schools. It's basically like an NFL draft but you can pay your way to the top of the draft, and the 2nd spot, and the 3rd spot...on a different tangent - I saw a tweet from a guy who covers NDSU, claiming that multiple NDSU players have received "6-figure NIL offers" from FBS schools. believe it if you choose.
Nope, but the timing of how everything went down makes me pretty sure PJ told him that, at the very least, AK should expect that they were going to look at some alternatives.Do you know he didn’t?
I saw an article linking Brosmer to MN dated 11/24….the day BEFORE the Wisconsin game. I don’t think PJ had his difficult conversation with AK until he knew he had something else coming.Nope, but the timing of how everything went down makes me pretty sure PJ told him that, at the very least, AK should expect that they were going to look at some alternatives.
Was also interesting to see he can find receivers in the red zone.I have no clue if he can play in the Big Ten. But I did watch about 15 minutes of his highlights on YouTube couple nice things I noticed was he never underthrew receivers and he seem pretty confident and decisive making decisions take it for what it’s worth.
I agree with the latter. The former seems to be more of what GH loves to do. Guys only leave when we want them to and the new guy is “can’t miss”. AK was awful. Thank goodness we got an alternative besides a true freshman. The Gophers still would be better off if AK had stayed.Nope, but the timing of how everything went down makes me pretty sure PJ told him that, at the very least, AK should expect that they were going to look at some alternatives.
It's not the 5-7 record that is the issue as much as how we achieved the 5-7 record. There will be up and down years. Fleck drawing it on a piece of paper doesn't make it more or less true.Fleck has said from the beginning that there would be an up and down track to progress. Perhaps if 2019 was an 8-5 year instead of 11-2, this year would have been easier to stomach for some!
I really doubt PJ ran off AK. But if you were a starter all year and found out they were bringing in someone that had a good chance to replace you, you might leave too. It's just how things are with the transfer portal now. QBs don't stay if they don't think they'll play. I agree that it would be nice to still have AK around.I agree with the latter. The former seems to be more of what GH loves to do. Guys only leave when we want them to and the new guy is “can’t miss”. AK was awful. Thank goodness we got an alternative besides a true freshman. The Gophers still would be better off if AK had stayed.
Being able to execute when playing from behind is a valuable skill too, could've used it this year a few times. Heck, the early part of 2019 would've been different had we not been able to execute when behind either.excited about this. However, New Hampshire was a bad team, played from behind a lot, possibly leading to inflated stats from the QB. Looks nice though, not afraid to step up and make a throw.
IMO Fleck was really hoping to pass much more this season. In our first game, against Nebby, we threw 64% of the time, ran 36%. And the third game, against NC, it was a 50/50 split. As it became more clear that AK wasn't all that good, we shifted to ever more running plays.Looking a bit at UNH their pass to run ration was the same as our run to pass ratio.
UNH 60% Pass
MN 60% Run.
They utilized the TE and their TE's had about 25 more catches than MN.
Order of Catches for UNH
1. Running back let the team in catches at 68
2. 6'3" WR
3. TE with 39 Catches
4. 6'4" WR
5 6'2" WR
We don't have the same size at WR and interesting that the RB led the team in catches.
Sure, it'd be nice to have more depth at QB, but if AK was still on the team, I don't think Mythical Max would have come here. Given a choice of the two, I'll take the Max over AK.I really doubt PJ ran off AK. But if you were a starter all year and found out they were bringing in someone that had a good chance to replace you, you might leave too. It's just how things are with the transfer portal now. QBs don't stay if they don't think they'll play. I agree that it would be nice to still have AK around.
He's actually ranked 31st. Took On3 a little bit to give him a transfer ranking.The total list is now up to 50 now. I thought maybe AK would sneak in at the bottom. It's not easy to be a starting QB in the B1G. Does anyone know how many D-1 QBs are in the portal? Just interested to know. I do hope he decides to stay on and compete for the starting or backup job in 2024-2025. People get hurt all the time. Maybe he can learn some things from another four year starter (Tanner being the first). He could still transfer next year.
Thank you for the heads up! This is getting interesting. Our new guy, Max Brosmer, is now down to 19 while AK has moved up to 29th! Come on AK, stay and prove you can improve, and be the guy in a year or two.He's actually ranked 31st. Took On3 a little bit to give him a transfer ranking.