Providence Journal: Donaldson asks: Who’s the greatest Gopher of them all?

BleedGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
61,974
Reaction score
18,168
Points
113
per the Providence Journal:

It’s a fun question, with the Patriots playing the Vikings this afternoon at the University of Minnesota’s TCF Bank Stadium.

Some would say Paul Giel, who was an all-American in two sports — football and baseball.

In three seasons as the star tailback in Minnesota’s single-wing offense, he ran and passed for 4,110 yards and 35 touchdowns, finishing second in the Heisman Trophy balloting in 1953 to Notre Dame’s Johnny Lattner.

But, instead of going to the NFL, Giel signed with the Giants as a pitcher.

He never made it big in baseball, though,

Pitching mostly in relief, he had an 11-9 record in 102 games over six seasons with the Giants, Pirates, Twins and Athletics.

So, no, the greatest Gopher of ‘em all isn’t Giel.

New England loyalists would say it’s Gino Cappelletti.

A Patriots Hall of Famer, Cappelletti played two seasons with Giel, as QB in the Gophers’ single wing offense, which featured the tailback as both passer and runner. Minnesota switched to a T-formation offense in ’54, the year after Giel graduated, and Cappelletti led the Gophers to a 7-2 record and was voted second-team, all-Big 10.

But it was as a kicker and receiver that he earned a spot on the all-time, all-AFL team, playing for the pats from their inception in 1960 through the AFL’s merger with the NFL in 1970.

“The Duke is a great guy, and was terrific for the Patriots, but he’s not the greatest Gopher of ‘em all.

That honor goes to Bruce Smith.

As tailback in the Gophers’ seemingly unstoppable single-wing attack, Smith led Minnesota to back-to-back undefeated seasons and successive national championships in 1940 and ’41, winning the Heisman Trophy in ’41.

He’s the Greatest Gopher of Them All.

http://www.providencejournal.com/sp...asks-whos-the-greatest-gopher-of-them-all.ece

Go Gophers!!
 



While I love these comparisons, but unfortunately the criteria is often a bit ambiguous

If one is talking about college football only - Pug Lund, Bruce Smith, Paul Giel, Bronko, even Sandy Stephens might get a vote or two (Bell and Eller might get some recognition, but I think we might be biased a bit by their pro careers)

There are a few whose college days were good (but not legendary) that made it big in the pros - Charlie Sanders, Gino Cappelletti, even Bud Grant to an extent

If one looks at a combination of both, there are four Gophers in both the College and Professional Halls of Fame - Bell, Eller, Bronko and Leo Nomellini (I do not think any other college team has this many in both halls)

But overall, I would lean towards Bronko
 






Top Bottom