Tubby deserves a bit of a mulligan this time around. In all fairness, he went out recruiting for 2010 looking for role players to surround Trevor Mbakwe and Royce White for the next couple years. This has been well documented, so I don't need to expand.
However, this latest class puts a ton of pressure on who Tubby brings in next year. I think 2011 needs to have at least two potential impact players, meaning there needs to be 4/5 stars next to their name on Scout and Rivals. This program cannot thrive with consistent recruiting classes that resemble the 2010 group. The only guy that I'm slightly excited about is Mo Walker, and he isn't even ranked in the top 100.
I understand that Minnesota doesn't have the "sex appeal" to automatically attract blue chip prospects like Kentucky, North Carolina, Louisville, Texas, Villanova, UCLA, etc., but I think Tubby Smith has the ability to bring these type of players in. Look at Royce White, Devoe Joseph, Rodney Williams and Ralph Sampson — those guys were all 4 star players. He can do.
Bottom line, I would start being concerned if Tubby's 2011 recruiting class isn't ranked in the top 3/4 of the Big Ten. He has a glut of role players right now. Look at it, we have the big bruiser (Iverson), the sharp shooter (Hoffarber), the lockdown defender (Nolen) and the slasher (Williams).
What's missing?
The impact player...
It's tough to rely on guys that "need a couple years."