gut, I agree that if this weren't Craig James' kid, it would probably not reach Mangino proportions, but while Dana Holgorsen (doesn't he have a Minnesota or Upper Midwest connection?) certainly has a right to his opinion, just because someone is given a scholarship that they may not deserve shouldn't enter into the calculation here. It's a bit of short-sighted stance to say "Hey, we let you play. Now we get to treat you like crap."
It's not like Adam James is alone in getting a "gift" scholarship. Even with the 85 scholarship limit, there are guys who get them who are undoubtedly lucky that for whatever reason--alumni connections, favor to local high school program, old friend of coach, the list goes on and on--somebody saw fit to make them an offer.
I saw the Craig James' interview during the Badger/Hurricane pre-game, and I thought he did a decent job of distancing himself from the Leach v. Texas Tech part of the story. He's Adam's dad for crying out loud. If one of my kids came to me with a story like this, I'd react the same way, as in "What the heck?" James is obviously in a rare position, as you have stated Gut, in that any comment he makes as a parent is going to spill over into a critique of Leach in a larger sense, which is why it's important that he step back and let the process play out, like he did last evening.
I view these things as "tip of the iceberg." If this stuff finds its way into the press, there's probably more there. On the farm, we use to say about rats that if you "saw one, you have a hundred."
This isn't Sunday school and football is a game, especially at this level, that requires extreme physical, psychological, and mental sacrifice. Hence, coaches have to push the envelope and sometimes that's going to spill over into behaviors that if fully known are going to make the general public squeamish. That said, you don't lock kids in equipment rooms.