My dad took me to see Bierman's final years at the U after I showed an interest in the warriors I saw in the Sunday peach sports section. I liked military history and football looked like it was military: offense, defense, helmets, physical struggle, casualties. The first teams I saw were the Bud Grant ex-WWII older teams of 1948-49, with Tonnemaker and Nomellini, Billy Bye, Gordy Soltau. The '49 team is one of the top Gopher teams I've ever seen - they were loaded. For the '49 Iowa game we had seats two rows behind the Gopher bench and I got a good look at Bierman, a legend, and all the players. Nomellini was pulled when the score hit 49-7 Gophers, and I'll never forget Leo the lion, a huge man, pulling off his helmet, shaking his head and looking up laughing. He was a 2 yr All-American. We left then and by the time we got to our car, the Gophers had scored again, winning 55-7. Without doubt the greatest game I saw in Memorial was the 1960 national championship game with Iowa - the media presence set a record. Sports Illustrated and LIFE magazine were covering it and scads of reporters from other publications. Iowa was leading 10-7 at the half. They were #1 in polls, we were # 2 in one, #3 in the other. The Gophers won in the second half when reserve QB Joe Salem threw a long pass that set up a TD, and our All-America center, Tom Brown, playing middle guard on defense, began driving the Iowa center back into their QB play after play, finally causing a fumble. It was brutal. Our FB, Roger Hagberg, was ripping Iowa's defensive line and broke one for another TD. Iowa wilted after that and the Gophers won 27-10, which put them #1 in both coaches and writers polls at the end of the season (bowl games didn't count in standings then). Next year's team was almost as good and the '62 team was the best defensive team I ever saw, holding 5 of 9 opponents scoreless and two others (should have been 3) to one touchdown. In Madison officials gave the conference championship to Wisconsin with two of the worst calls I've ever seen, one a roughing the passer call on Bobby Bell that was totally wrong - in fact he hit the Badger QB as he was passing and the ball never crossed the line of scrimmage, but fluttered straight up and was nabbed by a Goopher lineman. That, in the final minutes, would have clinched a 9-7 Gopher win and the title. To make it worse the official, named Jones, dropped a 15 yard penalty on Warmath because of his explosive reaction and that set up the winning Badger TD, 14-9 (earlier a TD by a Gopher running back was disallowed because of "helping the runner, a call I'd never seen or heard of, so we settle for a field goal). Paul Giel's farewell, a 21-21 tie with Wisconsin in the final game of '53 was almost as memorable.
There were many other famous games and players and the stadium is as described by others - the brickhouse, with cigar smoke drifting across the seated crowd. It was THE sports event in MN until Bud Grant built up the Vikings. Among other great games: tying Michigan's defending national championship team in the dismal 1950 season, 7-7; beating Pittsburgh on national TV, another huge day for Giel in '53; beating #10 USC in a true snow storm in 1955 - the California players looked miserable; knocking off #5 Michigan in '56; a big victory over #1 Michigan St in '61; almost beating OJ and USC in '68, 20-29. The Warmath-Devaney duel was epic while the Gophers maintained strength. But Devaney, losing the stats battle, would pull out a victory with a long pass or trick play - scores were 7-14, 21-26, 0-7, 14-17 in the first four contests, then the slaughter began. Cal Stoll's enormous and convincing upset of #1 Michigan in '77 was the real deal: a defensive masterpiece in the brickhouse, 16-0, that shocked the nation. But the 70s, 80s and 90s were largely a wasteland until '97 when I nearly fell off a kitchen chair reading that Lamanzer Williams had made a couple of All-America teams in Glen Mason's first year. No Gopher had made any All-America team, important or not, since 1971!
I could add twice as much as I've written, about individual players and teams, but moving to the Dome, a major project for AD Paul Giel, changed the game. Not until the present stadium was built, did some of the flavor of Memorial come back (Memorial's founding game was a win over Red Grange and Illinois in 1924). Sports Writer Don Riley tried desperately to save Memorial by modernizing it and the St. Paul Pioneer Press ran a half page drawing of what it would look like - it was short on rest rooms, concessions, and the basic structure was aging badly. The big money men in Minneapolis didn't want it any more and were all for a dome, which was a bargain since it served three teams.
In another Memorial memory, Paul Giel's one-man victory over a rated Michigan team in 1953, 22-0, could easily have been 52-0, but Fesler's teams were sloppy, with lots of turnovers, many in that game in Michigan's red zone. Giel was essentially the QB as we know it (left halfback under Wesler's system) and did all the punting and passing. He was the most elusive runner I ever saw, though not fast. An L.A. sports writer famously wrote: "Paul Giel looks like a man, but runs like a cat." he missed the '53 Heisman in the closest voting in the history of the trophy, playing 60 minutes per game.