Maryland’s QB Tagovailoa says he was offered $1.5MM to transfer to SEC Team

there is a reason why all the major conferences have been going to Washington DC to meet with Congressmen and Senators - they are begging and pleading for National NIL legislation. without a national set of rules, it's up to each state to act or not act to regulate NIL. A National bill would impose structure on the system.

But - it's only as good as the enforcement mechanism. If I put speed limits into effect on a highway, but there are no police or Highway Patrol units on patrol, people are still going to drive as fast as they want. in football, schools that want to bend the rules will bend the rules until one or more schools gets caught and faces real consequences.
 

there is a reason why all the major conferences have been going to Washington DC to meet with Congressmen and Senators - they are begging and pleading for National NIL legislation. without a national set of rules, it's up to each state to act or not act to regulate NIL. A National bill would impose structure on the system.

But - it's only as good as the enforcement mechanism. If I put speed limits into effect on a highway, but there are no police or Highway Patrol units on patrol, people are still going to drive as fast as they want. in football, schools that want to bend the rules will bend the rules until one or more schools gets caught and faces real consequences.
What national NIL legislation could there be?

Any federal law that says “naw you can’t make NIL money off X” would get the kibosh by the courts.

NCAA has more power to craft limits than anyone at this point, they choose not to.
 

What national NIL legislation could there be?

Any federal law that says “naw you can’t make NIL money off X” would get the kibosh by the courts.

NCAA has more power to craft limits than anyone at this point, they choose not to.

well, there have been several different bills proposed in Congress.

the point is right now, there are some states that have passed NIL legislation, and some states with no formal guidelines. a National bill would impose a structure that all states would have to follow.

as far as the courts, that remains to be seen. the Alston case was about education-related compensation and benefits - under the rationale that athletes could not be treated differently than 'regular' students. that is a long way from having some fat cat or collective throw 7-figure deals at athletes. A National bill could spell out what athletes have to do to 'earn' NIL money and also put reasonable limitations on NIL. I think that would pass muster with the Court.
 

well, there have been several different bills proposed in Congress.

the point is right now, there are some states that have passed NIL legislation, and some states with no formal guidelines. a National bill would impose a structure that all states would have to follow.

as far as the courts, that remains to be seen. the Alston case was about education-related compensation and benefits - under the rationale that athletes could not be treated differently than 'regular' students. that is a long way from having some fat cat or collective throw 7-figure deals at athletes. A National bill could spell out what athletes have to do to 'earn' NIL money and also put reasonable limitations on NIL. I think that would pass muster with the Court.
No chance.

The feds singling out college students to limit what they can earn wouldn’t last long.

The NCAA can impose limits as a requirement to participate in sports, but even that is limited.

The feds are in an entirely different position.
 

I think any legislation would be for transparency purposes only.

Who is supplying the NIL to an athlete?
How much is the NIL?

And also for tax purposes - is NIL earned income, subject to self-employment tax (I say yes)? Does the provider of the NIL issue a 1099-NEC to the athlete?
 


I think any legislation would be for transparency purposes only.

Who is supplying the NIL to an athlete?
How much is the NIL?

And also for tax purposes - is NIL earned income, subject to self-employment tax (I say yes)? Does the provider of the NIL issue a 1099-NEC to the athlete?
Right now at the very least NCAA requires (or at least did at the start) the athlete has to report NIL deals to the school.

That’s part of the reason for all these agencies the schools have worked with.

I sure hope the NIL entities are filing paperwork… but considering some tried to laughably pretend to be non profits until the IRS said “no”… I’m sure some are not.
 

But - it's only as good as the enforcement mechanism. If I put speed limits into effect on a highway, but there are no police or Highway Patrol units on patrol, people are still going to drive as fast as they want. in football, schools that want to bend the rules will bend the rules until one or more schools gets caught and faces real consequences.

Yep. Related, for those of you planning on heading out to the Rose Bowl the 101/210 highways are a racetrack full of idiot kids on later weekend evenings. The CHiP units are AWOL. They must be like…” are you f***ing crazy I’m not going out there”…smart
 

Yep. Related, for those of you planning on heading out to the Rose Bowl the 101/210 highways are a racetrack full of idiot kids on later weekend evenings. The CHiP units are AWOL. They must be like…” are you f***ing crazy I’m not going out there”…smart
No Ponch or John?
 




What national NIL legislation could there be?

Any federal law that says “naw you can’t make NIL money off X” would get the kibosh by the courts.

NCAA has more power to craft limits than anyone at this point, they choose not to.
Here your answer...

Senators offer latest bill aimed at college sports, NIL reform

A bipartisan trio of U.S. senators shared a draft Thursday morning of legislation that aims to create a uniform national law for how college athletes can make money and push many schools to provide more health care benefits for athletes.

The draft is one of at least three potential bills that have been floated on Capitol Hill this summer as the NCAA and leaders across college sports continue to ask Congress to help regulate how athletes can make money from their names, images and likenesses. This proposal -- co-authored by Sens. Cory Booker, Jerry Moran and Richard Blumenthal -- goes beyond NIL regulation by suggesting that NCAA schools should be required to be more transparent about their finances and set aside funds for post-career medical expenses and long-term guaranteed scholarships for athletes. The senators propose creating a non-government-operated corporation with the power to settle NIL disputes, certify agents and enforce other reforms, which include:

Health care: Establish a medical trust fund for sports-related injuries. Athletic departments that generate at least $20 million annually would be required to cover out-of-pocket medical expenses for athletes for two years after they finish playing. Athletic departments that generate at least $50 million annually would have to do the same for four years and provide athletics-related health care coverage while athletes were playing.

Draft eligibility: All college athletes can enter drafts for professional leagues without losing their NCAA eligibility if they decide to return to school within seven days of the draft ending.

Scholarship guarantees: Colleges would have to guarantee that athletes would keep their scholarships until they finish their undergraduate degrees as long as they remain in good academic standing and do not transfer.

Education: Schools could not attempt to discourage athletes from choosing particular academic majors. They would also be required to provide athletes with at least 15 hours per year of financial literacy and life skills training that could count as college credits.

Transparency: Schools would be required to report annually on their athletics revenue and expenses, how much money their coaches make, how much time athletes spent on their sports, academic outcomes, and the average value and total number of endorsement contracts athletes sign. The bill would make sure that specific contract details for endorsement deals were not made public or subject to public records requests.

The new corporation, dubbed the College Athletic Corporation, would work with existing associations like the NCAA to police certain areas of college sports. This group would be granted subpoena power to monitor whether all parties were obeying the framework established in the proposed law.
 

Here your answer...

Senators offer latest bill aimed at college sports, NIL reform

A bipartisan trio of U.S. senators shared a draft Thursday morning of legislation that aims to create a uniform national law for how college athletes can make money and push many schools to provide more health care benefits for athletes.

The draft is one of at least three potential bills that have been floated on Capitol Hill this summer as the NCAA and leaders across college sports continue to ask Congress to help regulate how athletes can make money from their names, images and likenesses. This proposal -- co-authored by Sens. Cory Booker, Jerry Moran and Richard Blumenthal -- goes beyond NIL regulation by suggesting that NCAA schools should be required to be more transparent about their finances and set aside funds for post-career medical expenses and long-term guaranteed scholarships for athletes. The senators propose creating a non-government-operated corporation with the power to settle NIL disputes, certify agents and enforce other reforms, which include:

Health care: Establish a medical trust fund for sports-related injuries. Athletic departments that generate at least $20 million annually would be required to cover out-of-pocket medical expenses for athletes for two years after they finish playing. Athletic departments that generate at least $50 million annually would have to do the same for four years and provide athletics-related health care coverage while athletes were playing.

Draft eligibility: All college athletes can enter drafts for professional leagues without losing their NCAA eligibility if they decide to return to school within seven days of the draft ending.

Scholarship guarantees: Colleges would have to guarantee that athletes would keep their scholarships until they finish their undergraduate degrees as long as they remain in good academic standing and do not transfer.

Education: Schools could not attempt to discourage athletes from choosing particular academic majors. They would also be required to provide athletes with at least 15 hours per year of financial literacy and life skills training that could count as college credits.

Transparency: Schools would be required to report annually on their athletics revenue and expenses, how much money their coaches make, how much time athletes spent on their sports, academic outcomes, and the average value and total number of endorsement contracts athletes sign. The bill would make sure that specific contract details for endorsement deals were not made public or subject to public records requests.

The new corporation, dubbed the College Athletic Corporation, would work with existing associations like the NCAA to police certain areas of college sports. This group would be granted subpoena power to monitor whether all parties were obeying the framework established in the proposed law.
At least from that description it doesn’t change anything NIL wise.
 


At least from that description it doesn’t change anything NIL wise.
It includes a requirement that teams have to report the average value and total number of endorsement contracts athletes sign. Personally, I think a lot of the NIL deals that get announced on Twitter are way inflated from what actually happens. $1.5M just isn't happening, maybe $50K or such like Texas and their OL, but not a chance that you'd pay $1.5M for a QB from Maryland. The price to get someone to leave Maryland is way lower than $1.5M. Shining some transparency on the deals IMO would help the overall NIL situation.
 



It includes a requirement that teams have to report the average value and total number of endorsement contracts athletes sign. Personally, I think a lot of the NIL deals that get announced on Twitter are way inflated from what actually happens. $1.5M just isn't happening, maybe $50K or such like Texas and their OL, but not a chance that you'd pay $1.5M for a QB from Maryland. The price to get someone to leave Maryland is way lower than $1.5M. Shining some transparency on the deals IMO would help the overall NIL situation.
Oh I agree the numbers are BS.

But most of the announcements that BS it are "up to" type numbers. Unless they have to report dollars paid ... deal can still say whatever BS.

Still even that doesn't really change anything.
 




Top Bottom