Lloyd: Is P.J. Fleck the most disrespected coach in America?

BleedGopher

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 11, 2008
Messages
58,249
Reaction score
11,125
Points
113
per Lloyd:

The Golden Gophers have been a strong force in the Big Ten’s West division for the past several years, having won eight games or more six times since 2012. Half of those instances have been under current head coach P.J. Fleck.

Fleck took over in Minneapolis for the 2017-18 year, and so far, that’s been his only full season there to finish with a losing record. As for his best season with the Gophers, they managed to hit a spectacular 11-2 record just two years after the sorry debut. It gave the program the most wins it’s seen in a single run since 1904.

Most recently, Minnesota football has had back-to-back 9-4 seasons, which is also a level of excellence that hasn’t been seen since the early 1900s. In both years, they won a bowl game to keep their postseason win streak alive (six-straight bowl wins, a total of four have been obtained while under Fleck).

When you combine all of that with previous accomplishments from his time at Western Michigan—three of four seasons saw records of 8-5 or better, including the university’s greatest of all time (13-1 in its 2016-17 run)—Fleck appears to be one of the top HCs in America today. The only problem is that he gets next to no recognition for it.


Go Gophers!!
 


fmlizard

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 19, 2012
Messages
4,928
Reaction score
4,760
Points
113
He is certainly underrated, but unless he can get win the West and/or beat Iowa, he and MN won't be properly respected.

Agree that "underrated" is a better descriptor than "disrespected"

Ever since the crescendo of the 2019 season where the Gophers got a ton of publicity, the national posture has been more "we're not paying close attention until you make us" than "the Gophers are trash and will get exposed"
 

hungan1

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
13,516
Reaction score
3,713
Points
113
He is certainly underrated, but unless he can get win the West and/or beat Iowa, he and MN won't be properly respected.
The loss against Bowling Green in 2021 hurts. If they had beaten BGSU, they would have won their first title. The national perception of the program would have been better.
 



West Fargo Gopher Fan

Section 114 Row 2
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
3,413
Reaction score
309
Points
83
Most disrespected? No way. His shtick isnt for everyone. He has even admitted that several times. Maybe underrated a little bit.
 


hungan1

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 20, 2011
Messages
13,516
Reaction score
3,713
Points
113
The BGSU loss had no impact on the Big Ten West race.
They would have to have beaten Iowa and BGSU. My mistake. The loss to Iowa was a heartbreaker 22-27.

WEST DIVISION
Iowa7-2.7784-13-14-2W410-4.7146-14-10-2L2
Wisconsin6-3.6673-23-15-1L19-4.6925-23-11-1W1
Minnesota6-3.6673-23-14-2W29-4.6924-34-11-0W3
Purdue6-3.6673-23-14-2W29-4.6924-24-21-0W3
Illinois4-5.4442-32-23-3W15-7.4173-42-30-0W1
Nebraska1-8.1111-40-41-5L63-9.2503-40-50-0L6
Northwestern1-8.1111-40-40-6L63-9.2503-40-50-0L6
 

gopherbadgerman

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2009
Messages
3,747
Reaction score
1,037
Points
113
The loss against Bowling Green in 2021 hurts. If they had beaten BGSU, they would have won their first title. The national perception of the program would have been better.
Agree. That and a lack of wins against Iowa and other ranked teams. Although if he had beaten Wisconsin in 2019 I think he might have been gone. He’s been good and I hope he stays a long time.
 




gopherjay

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2008
Messages
3,111
Reaction score
536
Points
113
Agree. That and a lack of wins against Iowa and other ranked teams. Although if he had beaten Wisconsin in 2019 I think he might have been gone. He’s been good and I hope he stays a long time.
Gone where? He will be here as long as Coyle is AD.
 

short ornery norwegian

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 9, 2011
Messages
16,763
Reaction score
9,636
Points
113
If you read the full article, it gets to the key issue here: Fleck's personality. Some people just don't like his personality, and that is held against him in these coaching rankings.

I happen to believe that if Fleck was a more 'traditional' coach with the same record, he would get more recognition. But, if he was a more traditional coach, would he get the same results? that's the catch-22 here. part of what makes Fleck unique is also what makes some people dislike him.
 

#2Gopher

Well-known member
Joined
May 18, 2010
Messages
8,759
Reaction score
2,717
Points
113
If you read the full article, it gets to the key issue here: Fleck's personality. Some people just don't like his personality, and that is held against him in these coaching rankings.

I happen to believe that if Fleck was a more 'traditional' coach with the same record, he would get more recognition. But, if he was a more traditional coach, would he get the same results? that's the catch-22 here. part of what makes Fleck unique is also what makes some people dislike him.
Other coaches don't like the fact that he is always comes up activities etc., to reach out to his players. Kind of like someone who does the minimum with their job as opposed to someone who always working to get better in one way or another.
 



Plato

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 14, 2019
Messages
1,802
Reaction score
1,244
Points
113
To me, the Texas A&M coach has to be the most disrespected because he has done less with more.
PJ rubs people the wrong way with his addiction for attention. Leading the team out, sprinting on the field at the end of a quarter, etc. are not necessary.
He needs to win the West before he is blended into the new schedule with the only chance for national recognition will be one of the three or four BIG teams to make the playoff games.
 


Word

Eats difficult conversations
Joined
Jun 7, 2009
Messages
11,494
Reaction score
7,607
Points
113
To me, the Texas A&M coach has to be the most disrespected because he has done less with more.
PJ rubs people the wrong way with his addiction for attention. Leading the team out, sprinting on the field at the end of a quarter, etc. are not necessary.
He needs to win the West before he is blended into the new schedule with the only chance for national recognition will be one of the three or four BIG teams to make the playoff games.
How would you feel about a coach putting his face all over billboards?
 

Bob_Loblaw

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
18,850
Reaction score
12,229
Points
113
To me, the Texas A&M coach has to be the most disrespected because he has done less with more.
PJ rubs people the wrong way with his addiction for attention. Leading the team out, sprinting on the field at the end of a quarter, etc. are not necessary.
He needs to win the West before he is blended into the new schedule with the only chance for national recognition will be one of the three or four BIG teams to make the playoff games.
Being a creepy troll who live on another team's board rubs people the wrong way.
 


Cayman

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 26, 2010
Messages
4,277
Reaction score
932
Points
113
They would have to have beaten Iowa and BGSU. My mistake. The loss to Iowa was a heartbreaker 22-27.

WEST DIVISION
Iowa7-2.7784-13-14-2W410-4.7146-14-10-2L2
Wisconsin6-3.6673-23-15-1L19-4.6925-23-11-1W1
Minnesota6-3.6673-23-14-2W29-4.6924-34-11-0W3
Purdue6-3.6673-23-14-2W29-4.6924-24-21-0W3
Illinois4-5.4442-32-23-3W15-7.4173-42-30-0W1
Nebraska1-8.1111-40-41-5L63-9.2503-40-50-0L6
Northwestern1-8.1111-40-40-6L63-9.2503-40-50-0L6
Non-conference games do not affect conference standings, except as maybe like the 8th tiebreaker in a 3-way tie for first place in the division to decide who actually plays in the championship game. Beating Iowa alone in 2021 would have been enough to get us to Indianapolis.

Probably affected bowl placement though. Would have been tougher to select 7-5 Penn State, 8-4 Purdue, and 8-4 Wisconsin ahead of 9-3 Minnesota.
 




Top Bottom