Brewster is doing a really solid job with the MN guys. To those who say they don't care where a guy is from, from a strictly business standpoint it costs us a lot less effort and time to get a James Farrow from MN that it would take to get a James Farrow from Texas or Florida or California.
That's all well and good, but you're looking solely at the expense side of the ledger. If you take players because they're Minnesotans, you're by definition going to have a poorer collection of talent than if you get the best players you can regardless of geography. Having a better team improves the income side of the ledger, thus enabling you to spend more on recruiting. Or, in some cases, the recruiting costs are subsidized as a necessary expense in order to field a legitimate team.
Schools like Notre Dame, Alabama, Tennessee, etc. recruit nationally because they know they can't stock a competitive roster with players from their own states. USC, Texas, Florida, etc. are afforded the luxury of signing the great majority of their players from within a few hours of campus because they can do that and still be in the national title hunt every year.
In terms of recruiting, Minnesota definitely falls in the scope of the former. If a player is worthy of a scholarship offer
and is from Minnesota, all the better, if only because: a) Minnesota fans like our own; and, more importantly, b) signability is a factor, and players closer to Minneapolis are, generally speaking, more likely to want to play close to family and friends. If we want to be a legitimate Big Ten team, and we ever start offering players just because they're from Minnesota, we might as well pack it in.
Otherwise, again, where the player is from should have absolutely zero impact on whether or not they are tendered. If we want to win at the highest levels (a goal I think most Gopher fans would agree with), we
must recruit nationally. If we want to field the best team full of Minnesotans possible, let's drop down to the MIAC, because that's the level where a team comprised of mostly/exclusively Minnesotans would be competitive.